Worked question 5 - Moles, Formulae and Equations
Subtract the crucible and lid mass (24.86 - 24.62 = 0.24 g magnesium; 25.02 - 24.62 = 0.40 g product) to find the oxygen mass by difference: 0.40 - 0.24 = 0.16 g. Convert each element's mass to moles using the given values, 24 for magnesium and 16 for oxygen: 0.24 / 24 = 0.01 mol Mg and 0.16 / 16 = 0.01 mol O. The equal mole amounts give a 1:1 ratio, so the empirical formula is MgO. This is a mole ratio, not a mass ratio: the element masses are 0.24:0.16, or 3:2.
Counting the Uncountable: Atoms, Formulae and the Mole
Original text written for Revision Library.
At the start of the nineteenth century, the chemist John Dalton proposed that every element is made of identical atoms, and that these atoms combine in fixed, whole-number ratios to form compounds. This idea explained something chemists had already noticed: a given compound always contains the same elements in the same proportion by mass, wherever the sample comes from. Dalton went further and assigned each element a relative atomic mass, a number showing how heavy its atoms are compared with one another. A few years later, the Italian scientist Amedeo Avogadro suggested that equal volumes of gases, at the same temperature and pressure, contain equal numbers of particles. His name was later given to a huge number, 6.02 * 10^23, which chemists use to count out a mole of any substance: an amount that always contains this same number of particles, however light or heavy those particles are. Relative formula mass, conservation of mass and the mole are still the basic tools chemists use today, from balancing an equation on paper to working out how many tonnes of limestone a quarry must supply to produce a given mass of quicklime, or how much of each gas is needed to manufacture ammonia in an industrial reactor.
A student, Aaliyah, investigates the empirical formula of magnesium oxide. She:
1. Weighs an empty crucible and lid.
2. Adds a coiled piece of magnesium ribbon and weighs the crucible, lid and magnesium.
3. Heats the crucible strongly on a pipe-clay triangle and tripod, lifting the lid slightly at intervals, until the magnesium has completely reacted and the mass is constant.
4. Allows the crucible to cool, then weighs the crucible, lid and solid product.
Her results:
Mass of empty crucible and lid = 24.62 g
Mass of crucible, lid and magnesium = 24.86 g
Mass of crucible, lid and solid product (after heating) = 25.02 g
Answer and mark scheme
Question 5
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| B1 | (a) 0.24 g cao (24.86 - 24.62) |
| B1 | (b) 0.16 g cao ((25.02 - 24.62) - mass of Mg from (a)); ft from candidate's (a) |
| M1 | (c) moles Mg = 0.24 / 24 = 0.01 mol; ft from (a) |
| M1 | (c) moles O = 0.16 / 16 = 0.01 mol; ft from (b) |
| A1 | (c) MgO cao, from a correctly identified 1:1 ratio |
| B1 | (d) to let air/oxygen into the crucible so that all of the magnesium can react (oe) |
| B1 | (e) to minimise the amount of white magnesium oxide smoke/powder that escapes; if too much escaped, the measured mass (and calculated formula) would be inaccurate/too low (oe) |
| 5-6 | (f) L3 A detailed and coherent evaluation is given, covering more than one source of error, each clearly linked to its effect on the calculated formula, together with at least one justified, practical improvement. The answer is well structured, using appropriate scientific terminology throughout. |
| 3-4 | (f) L2 Some relevant sources of error and/or improvements are described, with a partial explanation of how they would affect the calculated formula. The answer has some structure. |
| 1-2 | (f) L1 Simple, isolated statement(s) about a source of error or an improvement, with little or no explanation of the effect on the result. The answer may lack a logical structure. |
| 0 | (f) L0 No relevant content. |
- (a) Answer: 0.24 g
- (b) Answer: 0.16 g
- (c) Answer: MgO
- (d) Answer: Lifting the lid lets air (oxygen) into the crucible so that all of the magnesium can react completely.
- (e) Answer: Removing the lid completely would let more of the white magnesium oxide smoke escape, lowering the measured mass and making the calculated formula less accurate.
- (f) Indicative content:
- Magnesium oxide smoke/powder can escape from the crucible while the lid is lifted, or if it is not well fitted, so the final mass measured is lower than it should be.
- A lower final mass means the calculated mass of oxygen combined is too low, which could give an inaccurate mole ratio and formula.
- Magnesium can react with nitrogen in the air, as well as oxygen, forming magnesium nitride; this adds extra mass that is not accounted for by the mass of oxygen alone.
- If heating stops before all the magnesium has reacted, the final mass will be lower than expected and the calculated ratio of magnesium to oxygen will be inaccurate.
- The crucible should be heated, cooled, weighed, then reheated and reweighed repeatedly until the mass is constant, to check that the reaction is complete.
- Weighing the crucible while it is still hot can give an inaccurate reading, due to convection currents/expansion affecting the balance; it should be allowed to cool fully before each weighing.
- Improvement: use a lid with a small hole, which lets oxygen in but reduces the loss of solid smoke/product.
- Improvement: repeat the experiment and calculate a mean value for the mass of oxygen combined, to reduce the effect of random errors.
- (f) Answer: See levels/indicative content.









