Worked question 13 - Chromatography and Instrumental Analysis
Separating and Identifying Substances
Revision Library resource team
Chemists often need to check how pure a substance is, or work out what is in a mixture. Paper chromatography separates the different substances in a mixture, because they move through the paper at different rates, carried by a solvent. Comparing the distance a spot travels with the distance travelled by the solvent gives an Rf value, which can be compared with reference substances to identify the components of a mixture, such as a food colouring or an ink. Modern laboratories also use instrumental methods of analysis. These use machines, rather than test tubes, and give results that are faster, more sensitive and more accurate than traditional chemical tests, especially when only a very small sample is available. Flame emission spectroscopy is one such instrumental method: it identifies which metal ions are present in a sample, and how concentrated they are, by analysing the light given out when the sample is placed in a flame.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 13
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| B1 | (a) a contaminated (impure) sample melts over a range of temperatures, usually starting below the true melting point of the pure drug, oe |
| B1 | (a) so if the extracted drug melts over a range, rather than sharply at the known melting point of the pure drug, this shows it is contaminated, oe |
| B1 | (b) run a sample of the tablet coating alongside reference spots of pure dye X and pure dye Y, on the same chromatogram, using the same solvent, oe |
| B1 | (b) calculate the Rf value(s) of the spot(s) produced by the tablet coating sample |
| B1 | (b) if the tablet sample produces only one spot, matching the Rf value of dye X, it is not contaminated; a second spot matching the Rf value of dye Y would show contamination, oe |
| 5-6 | (c) L3 A well-reasoned evaluation is given, covering several advantages of flame emission spectroscopy (such as sensitivity, accuracy and the ability to measure concentration) applied clearly to why this matters for detecting trace metal contamination in tablets, leading to a justified conclusion. |
| 3-4 | (c) L2 Some relevant advantages of flame emission spectroscopy are given and applied to the tablet quality-control context, but the answer lacks a balanced evaluation or clear reasoning throughout. |
| 1-2 | (c) L1 A simple statement, or a short list, of one or two general points about instrumental methods is given, with little reference to the specific context of quality-controlling tablets for metal contamination. |
| 0 | (c) L0 No relevant content. |
- (a) Answer: If the extracted drug melts over a range of temperatures, rather than sharply at the known melting point of the pure drug, this shows the sample is contaminated.
- (b) Answer: Run the tablet coating alongside reference spots of dye X and dye Y on the same chromatogram. If only one spot appears, with the same Rf value as dye X, the coating is pure; an extra spot matching dye Y's Rf value would show contamination with dye Y.
- (c) Indicative content:
- flame emission spectroscopy is far more sensitive than chemical tests, so it can detect very low (trace) concentrations of metal contamination that a chemical test might miss
- trace contamination is exactly the kind of small-sample, low-concentration analysis that instrumental methods are best suited to
- it is more accurate than chemical tests, which often rely on an analyst's subjective judgement, e.g. judging a colour change or a flame colour by eye
- it can determine the concentration of any contaminating metal ion present, not just confirm its presence, which matters for quality control (a tablet may be within or outside a safe limit)
- results are fast, which suits the high throughput needed in pharmaceutical quality control, where many tablets or batches must be tested
- it can identify more than one metal ion present in a mixture from a single sample or spectrum
- counterbalancing point: the equipment is expensive and requires trained staff, but for a pharmaceutical company this cost is justified by the need for precise, reliable safety data
- conclusion: flame emission spectroscopy is more suitable overall, because trace contamination requires the sensitivity and quantitative concentration data that chemical tests cannot reliably provide
- (c) Answer: Levels of response part, no single correct answer; credit a balanced evaluation covering the high sensitivity of flame emission spectroscopy (able to detect trace/low concentrations of contaminating metal ions), its accuracy compared with chemical tests that rely on an analyst's judgement, its ability to measure the concentration of any contaminant (important for checking against a safety limit), and its speed (suiting high-throughput quality control), balanced against the cost of the equipment and staff training, leading to a justified conclusion. See indicative content.









