Some sociologists have argued that sociology can be a value-free, objective science, similar to physics or chemistry, while others are more sceptical of this claim.
Explain two criticisms sociologists make of the claim that sociology can be a fully value-free, objective science.
Answer
Researchers' values can influence topic selection and operational definitions, so complete neutrality is difficult even with systematic methods. Participants interpret and react to researchers, so findings depend on meanings and context rather than passive objects governed by unchanging laws.
Mark scheme
| B1 | Identify researcher values shaping topic choice, categories or interpretation as one criticism. |
| B1 | Explain how background assumptions can influence research despite attempts to remain neutral. |
| B1 | Identify participants' meanings and agency as a distinct challenge to a fully natural-science model. |
| B1 | Explain how people interpreting or reacting to research makes findings context-dependent rather than passive observations of fixed objects. |
| B1 | Add new relevant illustration without inferring that all systematic enquiry or efforts towards objectivity are impossible. Accept this alternative route if it meets the same demand: Funding priorities can shape topic choice and research categories, if distinguished from the separate issue of participants' meanings. Distinct-credit limit: Do not infer that findings are arbitrary merely because researchers have values or participants exercise agency. Examples are illustrative: credit any defensible equivalent or alternative that answers the printed demand with the required distinct development. Accepted alternatives: Funding priorities can shape topic choice and research categories, if distinguished from the separate issue of participants' meanings. Exclusions: Do not infer that findings are arbitrary merely because researchers have values or participants exercise agency. |