Improving Eyewitness Testimony: The Cognitive Interview - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
9 original exam-style questions - 3 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Improving Eyewitness Testimony: The Cognitive Interview revision guideWrite-in editionMore A Level Psychology practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 15 of A Level Psychology Topic Workbook 1 and chapter 14 of A Level Psychology 10-Minute Tests 1.
2.8 Improving Eyewitness Testimony: The Cognitive Interview
Question 1
- states a practical step, e.g. corroborate CI details with independent evidence, or audio/video record interviews, or flag uncorroborated details in reports oeB1
- gives a reason, e.g. corroboration prevents reliance on potentially incorrect CI details, or recordings allow later review and protection against suggestion oeB1
- Answer: Example answer: Corroborate CI-derived details with independent evidence, because this prevents investigators or courts relying on details that may be incorrect.
Question 2
- states that witnesses are asked to mentally recreate the physical and emotional context of the original event oeB1
- explains that reinstating context provides environmental and internal cues that aid retrieval of stored memories oeB1
- Answer: Witnesses are asked to mentally recreate the scene and their feelings at the time, because restoring environmental and internal cues helps retrieval and improves recall of event details.
Question 3
- states that witnesses are asked to recall the event from another person's viewpoint or to imagine a different vantage point oeB1
- explains that changing perspective can trigger different cues and reduce reliance on schema-driven reconstructions oeB1
- Answer: Witnesses are asked to describe the incident from another person's viewpoint or a different position, which can activate alternative cues and reveal details not retrieved when using a single perspective.
Question 4
- states that witnesses are asked to recall events in a different temporal order, such as backwards oeB1
- explains that reversing order disrupts normal narrative reconstruction, reducing the insertion of expected details and revealing additional memories oeB1
- Answer: Witnesses are asked to recount events in reverse order, which disrupts usual narrative reconstruction and can reduce expectation-driven errors while revealing details omitted in forward recall.
Question 5
- selects an appropriate CI technique, e.g. reinstating the context, or report everything, or changing perspective caoM1
- explains how the chosen technique operates in general terms, e.g. reinstating context prompts environmental and internal cues; report everything prompts even trivial visual details oeM1
- applies the technique specifically to Erin's case, e.g. reinstating the late-night scene, lighting, smell, her emotional state to cue visual memories of the attacker or clothing oeA1
- explains why this is likely to increase visual detail compared with her current focus on sound, linking to cue-dependent retrieval oeA1
- offers a brief acknowledgement of a limitation, e.g. risk of increased incorrect details or need for careful interviewer control oeB1
- justifies the choice overall, weighing benefit of increased correct detail against the limitation and concluding the chosen technique is most suitable oeA1
- Answer: Example answer: Reinstating the context would be chosen. The interviewer would encourage Erin to mentally recreate the late-night street, the lighting, smells, and her emotional state, because restoring environmental and internal cues can trigger visual memories that are not accessed when she focuses on sound alone. Applied to Erin, this could prompt recall of clothing, the attacker's height or direction of movement. This is likely to increase correct visual details, though it should be done carefully because context reinstatement can also increase incorrect details if leading prompts are used.
Question 6
- identifies a relevant disadvantage, e.g. enhanced CI takes more time to conduct or requires specialist training for interviewers oeM1
- explains why the identified factor is a disadvantage, e.g. longer interviews reduce the number that can be conducted per shift or training budgets are limited oeA1
- links the disadvantage to practical consequences, e.g. delayed investigative leads, backlog of cases, or inconsistent application across forces oeM1
- explains the consequence in context, e.g. delayed memory-sensitive enquiries may reduce evidence quality or create public-safety risks oeA1
- provides a brief example or further elaboration, e.g. small local forces may lack funds or staff to implement enhanced CI fully oeB1
- concludes why the disadvantage matters overall, weighing the trade-off between improved recall and resource constraints oeA1
- Answer: Example answer: Enhanced CI requires longer, more careful interviews and trained interviewers. This is a disadvantage because it reduces how many interviews a police team can carry out and requires training budgets and time that some forces lack. Practically this can delay investigations and reduce the chance of obtaining timely evidence, so although enhanced CI may increase recall, resource constraints may limit its routine use and value in busy or underfunded forces.
Question 7
- identifies one interpersonal technique, e.g. establishing rapport and using open, non-leading questions oeM1
- explains how this reduces anxiety and helps recall, e.g. a calm rapport lowers stress so memory retrieval is less impaired and witness feels safer to report details oeA1
- identifies a second interpersonal technique, e.g. minimising interruptions and allowing the witness to speak without distraction oeM1
- explains how this helps recall, e.g. uninterrupted free recall preserves the witness's retrieval cues and prevents loss of focus, increasing correct detail reported oeA1
- Answer: Example answer: Enhanced CI builds rapport with the witness and uses open, non-leading questioning to reduce anxiety, which can improve access to memory. It also minimises interruptions and interviewer distraction so the witness can maintain retrieval cues and speak freely, reducing loss of detail. Both approaches make retrieval conditions more supportive and so can increase correct recall.
Question 8
- Level 4 Knowledge of the cognitive interview and enhanced CI is accurate and well detailed. Evaluation is thorough and shows a wide range of developed points, including methodological critique, practical implications, and consideration of supporting and challenging evidence. Material is used interactively to reach a balanced judgement about CI's value for improving eyewitness accuracy. Specialist terminology is used appropriately and answer is clearly organised.13-16
- Level 3 Knowledge of the cognitive interview and enhanced CI is clear with some development. Evaluation is present and generally effective, covering strengths and limitations, and uses some empirical evidence. The answer makes a balanced judgement but may lack depth in places. The response is mostly coherent and uses some specialist terms appropriately.9-12
- Level 2 Knowledge is present but limited in depth or detail. Evaluation is superficial or one-sided, with limited use of empirical evidence. Application to practical contexts may be brief. The answer shows some organisation but may be partially descriptive.5-8
- Level 1 Knowledge is minimal or inaccurate. Evaluation is weak or absent, and there is little or no use of evidence. Answer lacks structure and specialist terminology is missing or used inappropriately.1-4
- Level 0 No creditable content.0
- Indicative content:
- AO1: Fisher and Geiselman (1992) components of the original cognitive interview: report everything, reinstate the context, recall from a changed perspective, recall in reverse order.
- AO1: The enhanced cognitive interview adds focus on social aspects such as establishing rapport, reducing witness anxiety, minimising interruptions and interviewer distraction, and adapting questioning style to the witness.
- AO1: Mechanisms underlying CI: mental reinstatement and cue-dependent retrieval, disruption of schema-driven reconstruction, multiple retrieval routes.
- AO3: Empirical support: Kohnken et al. meta-analysis showing CI increases correct detail but also increases incorrect detail, so CI raises quantity and also error risk; Milne and Bull showing report everything and context reinstatement are particularly effective and work well in combination.
- AO3: Methodological critiques: many supporting studies are laboratory-based with student samples and staged events, limiting ecological validity; field studies show more mixed results and variation by interviewer skill and witness stress.
- AO3: Practical issues: enhanced CI requires interviewer training and more time, creating resource constraints and possible inconsistent application across forces; recording and corroboration are required to manage increased incorrect details.
- AO3: Ethical and legal considerations: need to avoid leading questions during CI, and to ensure witnesses are not pressured; courts must be informed about the nature of CI-derived evidence and the risk of increased incorrect details.
- AO3: Balanced judgement: CI is a valuable tool that can produce more useful leads and increase correct recall when used properly, but it is not a panacea; its benefits must be balanced against training, time, ecological validity concerns and the legal requirement to corroborate CI-derived details.
Question 9
- outlines the key finding: CI yields more correct detail than standard interviews but also more incorrect detail overall, as reported in Kohnken et al.'s meta-analysis oeM1
- quantifies or clarifies that gains in correct detail were statistically significant while incorrect details also rose, reducing net precision oeA1
- identifies a relevant legal implication, e.g. need for caution when relying on quantity of details as an indicator of accuracy oeM1
- explains the implication, e.g. more careful corroboration is required, such as seeking independent evidence for key points, or giving jury guidance about possible increased false details oeA1
- offers a further practical consequence, e.g. police may need to record CI interviews fully and highlight which details are corroborated, or defence may challenge CI-derived evidence in court oeB1
- concludes how the implication affects the balance between increased information and legal reliability, e.g. CI is valuable but requires safeguards to prevent miscarriages of justice oeA1
- Answer: Example answer: Kohnken et al. reported that CI elicits significantly more correct details than standard interviews, but it also increases the number of incorrect details. This implies that while CI can provide useful additional leads, legal professionals must be cautious: the quantity of detail alone is not proof of accuracy and key CI-derived details should be corroborated before being used as firm evidence. Courts and police should therefore record CI interviews and apply safeguards so that the risk of false incriminating detail is minimised.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.