Skip to the worksheet
Revision Library
Choose a subject

Comprehension: Non-Fiction Set 6 - Worksheets, Questions and Revision

24 original exam-style questions - 7 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.

This topic is chapter 6 of 11+ English Ages 10-11 Topic Workbook 3.

Revision Library
revisionlibrary.co.uk
11+ · English - Reading and Writing

1.2-6 Comprehension: Non-Fiction Set 6

GL ASSESSMENT / CSSE 11+ Entrance English (GL Assessment / CSSE style) · about 45 minutes
Total Marks
Name: _______________________________    Date: ____ / ____ / ______
Answer ALL questions.

Salad Without Soil: The Vertical Farm in a Coventry Car Park

Source written for Revision Library (original, copyright-free).

Just before six o'clock on a wet Tuesday morning, Priya Chandrasekaran swipes a keycard against a metal door on the third floor of a disused multi-storey car park in Coventry and steps into a warm, purple-lit room that smells faintly of basil. The space that once held forty parked cars now holds row upon row of stacked metal shelving, twelve trays high, each one lined with pale green seedlings growing without a single grain of soil. Fine mist drifts between the shelves, and a soft electrical hum fills the air. Priya has not come to park a car. She has come to check on nine thousand lettuces, a job she does every morning before the rest of the city has woken up.

The car park where Priya works had stood almost empty for years. Fewer shoppers were driving into the city centre, since more people were cycling to work, taking the bus, or having their groceries delivered to their front door, and two of the car park's four floors had not been used since 2016. At the same time, farmers across the country were struggling to find enough space to grow food. On 14/03/2019, a government report warned that the amount of land available for farming in England was shrinking every year, squeezed by new housing and warehouses, and that the country needed to find new ways to grow fruit and vegetables closer to the towns and cities where people actually lived. A small agricultural start-up spotted an opportunity: instead of building a farm outwards across a field, why not build one upwards, inside a building that was already standing empty?

Inside the car park, no soil is used at all. Each tray holds seedlings whose roots dangle into a shallow stream of water mixed with dissolved nutrients, a method known as hydroponics. Rows of LED lights glow a deep purple-pink above every shelf, since plants mainly need red and blue light to grow rather than the full rainbow of colours found in daylight, and using only these wavelengths saves electricity. Sensors dotted around the room constantly measure the temperature, humidity and level of carbon dioxide in the air, adjusting fans and vents automatically to keep every tray growing at exactly the right pace. Because the shelves are stacked twelve trays high rather than spread across a single level, one small room can produce roughly the same amount of lettuce as three and a half hectares of outdoor farmland, an area larger than five football pitches.

Growing food this way brings several advantages. Because the room's climate is entirely controlled, lettuces can be harvested every day of the year, whatever the weather is doing outside, and a head of lettuce grown here uses around ten times less water than one grown in an open field, since none of the nutrient-rich water is lost to evaporation or drains away into the surrounding soil. No pesticides are needed either, because the sealed room keeps out the insects and fungal spores that usually damage outdoor crops. Once picked, the lettuces travel less than two miles to the restaurants, school kitchens and a nearby food bank that buy them, rather than being driven for hundreds of miles from a farm in another part of the country or shipped in from overseas.

The farm's impact reaches beyond the food itself. Local primary schools now bring classes to peer through a viewing window built into one wall, watching seedlings grow from tiny sprouts to full heads of lettuce within a matter of weeks, and pupils are shown how the same amount of water can be reused again and again rather than being poured away after a single use. A nearby college has also begun sending horticulture students to help tend the trays as part of their coursework, giving them hands-on experience of a growing method they might otherwise only read about in a textbook. For Priya, who left a desk job in logistics to join the farm two years ago, the steady stream of curious visitors is one of the most rewarding parts of the work.

Not every food expert is convinced that vertical farms like this one are the answer to the country's food problems. Dr Oliver Bramwell, who studies food security at a university in Leeds, points out that the technology has real limits. 'Lettuces, herbs and salad leaves grow quickly and do not need much energy to flourish, which is why they work so well in a place like this,' he explains. 'But staple crops such as wheat, potatoes and rice, the foods that actually keep most of the country fed, need far more space and far more light than any indoor farm could realistically provide. Running rows of LED lights around the clock also uses a great deal of electricity, so unless that electricity comes from renewable sources, some of the environmental savings can be cancelled out.' Bramwell believes vertical farms have a genuine role to play in feeding towns and cities, but only as one part of a much larger system that still relies heavily on traditional outdoor farming.

By the time the morning shift ends, Priya has filled forty crates with freshly cut lettuce, each one destined for a kitchen within a couple of miles of the old car park. She steps out onto what was once the building's open-air top deck, now covered with solar panels that help power the lights three floors below, and looks out over the rooftops of Coventry as the city properly wakes up around her. It is an unlikely sight: rows of glossy salad leaves thriving where cars once queued for a parking space, tended not under an open sky but beneath rows of purple light. It is not, as Dr Oliver Bramwell would remind her, a complete answer to how a growing population will be fed. But for the restaurants, school kitchens and food bank that rely on her trays each week, it is proof that empty buildings in the middle of a city can still be made to grow something worth eating.

1
What effect does the comparison 'an area larger than five football pitches' (paragraph 3) have on the reader?
(2)
2
Using paragraph 4, give two advantages of growing lettuces in this controlled indoor environment.
(2)
3
Using paragraph 4, give three different types of buyer mentioned that the lettuces are sold to.
(3)
4
What does 'sealed' mean, as used in paragraph 4 ('the sealed room keeps out the insects')?
  • A) completely closed off, letting nothing in or out
  • B) brightly lit with coloured lights
  • C) very expensive to build and run
  • D) recently cleaned and tidied
5
Using paragraph 5, explain how the farm supports the education of local schoolchildren and college students.
(2)
6
Using paragraph 6, give two limitations of vertical farming that Dr Oliver Bramwell identifies.
(2)
7
According to paragraph 6, what is Dr Oliver Bramwell's area of study, and in which city does he work?
(2)
8
What does 'flourish' mean, as used in paragraph 6 ('do not need much energy to flourish')?
  • A) grow well and thrive
  • B) die quickly and unexpectedly
  • C) change colour over time
  • D) travel a long distance
9
Using paragraph 2, give two reasons why fewer shoppers were driving into the city centre.
(2)
10
What does 'squeezed' mean, as used in paragraph 2 ('squeezed by new housing and warehouses')?
  • A) reduced or put under pressure by competing demands
  • B) increased rapidly in size
  • C) cleaned thoroughly
  • D) sold at a much lower price
11
According to paragraph 2, on what date did a government report warn that farmland in England was shrinking?
(1)
12
Using paragraph 3, explain why the growing lights in the car park glow purple-pink rather than white.
(2)
13
According to paragraph 3, what method is used to grow the seedlings without soil?
(1)
14
According to paragraph 1, how many trays high is each stack of shelving?
(1)
15
According to paragraph 1, in which city is the car park located?
(1)
16
Using paragraph 1, give two details, other than its location, that the writer provides about the room Priya enters.
(2)
17
How many lettuces does Priya check on every morning, according to paragraph 1?
(1)
18
Explain why watching the water being reused, rather than poured away after a single use (paragraph 5), might be a particularly valuable lesson for the schoolchildren to learn.
(3)
19
In your own words, explain the problem Dr Oliver Bramwell describes with relying on electricity that may not come from renewable sources (paragraph 6).
(3)
20
Explain why the writer chooses to include a direct quotation from Dr Oliver Bramwell in paragraph 6, rather than simply summarising his views.
(2)
21
What effect does the phrase 'rows of glossy salad leaves thriving where cars once queued for a parking space' (paragraph 7) have on the reader?
(2)
22
Why does the writer choose to end the passage with a return to Priya on the rooftop, rather than ending with Dr Oliver Bramwell's quotation in paragraph 6?
(3)
23
In your own words, summarise the main benefits of growing food this way described across paragraphs 4 and 5.
(3)
24
'This passage suggests that vertical farming is entirely the solution to Britain's food problems.' Do you agree? Use evidence from at least two different parts of the passage to support your answer.
(3)
Mark scheme · 1.2-6 Comprehension: Non-Fiction Set 6

Question 1

  • identifies that it gives the reader a vivid, relatable sense of scaleB1
  • explains that it emphasises how surprising or impressive it is that one small, stacked room can match the output of such a large area of outdoor farmland - oeB1
  • Answer: The comparison gives the reader a vivid, relatable sense of scale, emphasising how surprising it is that one small, stacked room can match the output of an area of outdoor farmland larger than five football pitches.

Question 2

  • accept any one of: lettuces can be harvested every day of the year, whatever the weather; a lettuce grown here uses around ten times less water than one grown in an open field; no pesticides are neededB1
  • accept a second, different advantage from the same listB1
  • Answer: Any two of: harvested every day of the year regardless of weather; uses around ten times less water; no pesticides needed.

Question 3

  • restaurantsB1
  • school kitchensB1
  • a nearby food bankB1
  • Answer: Restaurants, school kitchens and a nearby food bank.

Question 4

  • AB1
  • Answer: A) completely closed off, letting nothing in or out

Question 5

  • identifies that primary school pupils watch seedlings grow through a viewing window and learn how water is reusedB1
  • identifies that college horticulture students gain hands-on experience tending the trays as part of their courseworkB1
  • Answer: Primary school pupils watch seedlings grow through a viewing window and learn how water is reused, while college horticulture students gain hands-on experience tending the trays as part of their coursework.

Question 6

  • staple crops such as wheat, potatoes and rice need far more space and light than an indoor farm could realistically provideB1
  • running LED lights around the clock uses a great deal of electricity, and unless it comes from renewable sources some of the environmental savings can be cancelled outB1
  • Answer: Staple crops such as wheat, potatoes and rice need far more space and light than an indoor farm could provide, and running LED lights around the clock uses a great deal of electricity, which can cancel out some of the environmental savings unless it comes from renewable sources.

Question 7

  • food securityB1
  • LeedsB1
  • Answer: Food security, at a university in Leeds.

Question 8

  • AB1
  • Answer: A) grow well and thrive

Question 9

  • accept any one of: more people were cycling to work; more people were taking the bus; more people were having their groceries delivered to their front doorB1
  • accept a second, different reason from the same listB1
  • Answer: Any two of: cycling to work; taking the bus; having groceries delivered to their front door.

Question 10

  • AB1
  • Answer: A) reduced or put under pressure by competing demands

Question 11

  • 14/03/2019B1
  • Answer: 14/03/2019

Question 12

  • identifies that plants mainly need red and blue light to grow, rather than the full rainbow of colours found in daylightB1
  • identifies that using only these wavelengths saves electricity - oeB1
  • Answer: Plants mainly need red and blue light to grow rather than the full rainbow of colours in daylight, so using only these wavelengths of light saves electricity.

Question 13

  • hydroponics (accept: roots dangling into water mixed with nutrients)B1
  • Answer: Hydroponics

Question 14

  • twelve (accept: twelve trays high)B1
  • Answer: Twelve

Question 15

  • CoventryB1
  • Answer: Coventry

Question 16

  • accept any one of: warm and purple-lit; smells faintly of basil; fine mist drifts between the shelves; a soft electrical hum fills the air; the space once held forty parked carsB1
  • accept a second, different detail from the same listB1
  • Answer: Any two of: warm and purple-lit; smells faintly of basil; fine mist between the shelves; a soft electrical hum; once held forty parked cars.

Question 17

  • Nine thousandB1
  • Answer: Nine thousand

Question 18

  • identifies that this teaches children about conserving, or not wasting, a limited resourceB1
  • explains that seeing a specific example makes an abstract idea, such as sustainability, concrete and memorable rather than something only read about - oeB1
  • identifies that this is a lesson the children could apply more widely, beyond the farm itself - oeB1
  • Answer: Seeing water being reused teaches children not to waste a limited resource, and watching this happen in person makes an abstract idea like sustainability concrete and memorable rather than something only read about, which is a lesson they could apply more widely beyond the farm itself.

Question 19

  • identifies that running LED lights around the clock uses a great deal of electricity - oeB1
  • identifies that this electricity might not come from renewable sources - oeB1
  • explains the implied consequence: that the farm's environmental benefits could be reduced or cancelled out as a result - oeB1
  • Answer: Keeping the LED lights running all day and night uses a large amount of electricity, and if that electricity is not generated from renewable sources, the environmental benefits of growing food this way could end up being reduced or cancelled out.

Question 20

  • identifies that Bramwell is an expert with relevant credentials (he studies food security at a university), so a quotation adds authority and credibilityB1
  • explains that hearing his own words lets the reader engage with his caution more directly and personally than a plain summary would - oeB1
  • Answer: Because Bramwell is an expert who studies food security at a university, quoting his words directly adds authority and credibility to his caution, and lets the reader engage with his concerns in a more direct, personal way than a summary could.

Question 21

  • identifies that the phrase creates a vivid contrast between the building's old and new usesB1
  • explains that it emphasises how transformed or surprising the space now is, creating a sense of wonder at what has replaced something mundane - oeB1
  • Answer: The phrase creates a vivid contrast between the car park's old and new uses, emphasising how transformed and surprising the space now is, and creating a sense of wonder at what has replaced something as mundane as a parking space.

Question 22

  • identifies that returning to Priya links back to the opening scene, giving the passage a circular, frame-like structureB1
  • identifies that the ending gives a vivid, hopeful, tangible image of achievement rather than closing on a note of doubtB1
  • explains that Bramwell's caution is still referenced ('not... a complete answer'), so the balance of the passage is not lost even though it ends on a hopeful note - oeB1
  • Answer: Returning to Priya gives the passage a circular structure that links back to its opening scene, and leaves the reader with a vivid, hopeful image of what has been achieved rather than a note of doubt; the reference to Bramwell's caution in the closing paragraph still keeps the ending balanced rather than simply celebratory.

Question 23

  • identifies environmental/resource benefits: less water use, no pesticides needed, food travels a shorter distance to buyers - oeB1
  • identifies wider community and education benefits: school visits through the viewing window and college students gaining hands-on experience - oeB1
  • identifies that these benefits reach local buyers such as restaurants, school kitchens and a food bank - oeB1
  • Answer: Growing food this way uses far less water, needs no pesticides, and travels only a short distance to local restaurants, school kitchens and a food bank; it also brings wider benefits to the community, letting schoolchildren watch how food is grown through a viewing window and giving college horticulture students hands-on experience tending the trays.

Question 24

  • recognises that the statement is not entirely accurate, since the passage is broadly positive but also includes genuine cautionB1
  • supports this with evidence of clear benefits, e.g. the space and water savings described in paragraph 3 or 4, or the community/education benefits in paragraph 5B1
  • supports this with evidence of a genuine limitation, e.g. Dr Oliver Bramwell's warning about staple crops and electricity use in paragraph 6, reaching a balanced overall judgementB1
  • Answer: The passage is not entirely one-sided: it presents clear benefits, such as the space and water savings described in paragraphs 3 and 4 and the community and education benefits in paragraph 5, but it also gives real weight to Dr Oliver Bramwell's warning that vertical farms cannot grow staple crops and rely on electricity that may not be renewable (paragraph 6), so the overall view is balanced rather than entirely positive.

Mark your answers

Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.

Question 1

2 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 2

2 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 3

3 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 4

1 mark
Choose an answer

Question 5

2 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 6

2 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 7

2 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 8

1 mark
Choose an answer

Question 9

2 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 10

1 mark
Choose an answer

Question 11

1 mark

Question 12

2 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 13

1 mark

Question 14

1 mark

Question 15

1 mark

Question 16

2 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 17

1 mark

Question 18

3 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 19

3 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 20

2 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 21

2 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 22

3 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 23

3 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?

Question 24

3 marks
Did your answer earn the marks?
Mark my answers

Worksheets are written for Revision Library and come with a full mark scheme; a few English packs quote an out-of-copyright text, and name it on the page. Exam board names and specification codes say which qualification a pack suits: we are not affiliated with, endorsed by or approved by any exam board, and no past-paper question is reproduced here. Rights queries: hello@revisionlibrary.co.uk