The Role of Attitudes in Society in Medical Change, c1250-Present - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
10 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
The Role of Attitudes in Society in Medical Change, c1250-Present revision guideMore GCSE History practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 12 of GCSE History Topic Workbook 1 and chapter 12 of GCSE History 10-Minute Tests 1.
1.12 The Role of Attitudes in Society in Medical Change, c1250-Present
You may use the following in your answer:
- fears about vaccine safety and religious objections
- distrust of rapid government interference in private life
You must also use information of your own.
You may use the following in your answer:
- examples where religious or cultural attitudes slowed the acceptance of new medical ideas
- examples where public attitudes prompted government action, such as the Public Health Act 1875
You must also use information of your own. 4 marks are available for spelling, punctuation, grammar and specialist terminology.
Question 1
- The ChurchB1
- Answer: The Church
Question 2
- 1796B1
- Answer: 1796
Question 3
- Florence NightingaleB1
- Answer: Florence Nightingale
Question 4
- the Thomas splintB1
- Answer: The Thomas splint
Question 5
- fear of contradicting Galen and university teachingB1
- religious or cultural discomfort with dissection and challenging traditional authorityB1
- Answer: They feared contradicting Galen and the universities, and there was religious and cultural discomfort with dissection and challenging tradition.
Question 6
- some surgeons doubted germ theory and did not believe invisible organisms caused wound infectionB1
- practical objections and professional conservatism, such as the extra time and cost involved and reluctance to change accepted techniquesB1
- Answer: They doubted germ theory and some objected on practical or professional-conservative grounds, such as extra time, cost and reluctance to change established methods.
Question 7
- Robert KochB1
- Answer: Robert Koch
Question 8
- belief that local government or private charities, not central government, should deal with poverty and diseaseB1
- fear that state intervention would be expensive and interfere with individual freedom or local business interestsB1
- Answer: A belief that local bodies or charities should handle problems, and fear that state intervention would be costly and intrusive.
Question 9
- Level 1 Identifies one or two simple reasons why attitudes affected reception, with little supporting detail or explanation.1-3
- Level 2 Explains one or two reasons with some accurate supporting detail, beginning to show how attitudes influenced reception or policy.4-6
- Level 3 Explains several reasons clearly, supported by accurate detail and analysis of how attitudes affected both popular reaction and political decisions.7-9
- Level 4 Provides a well-developed explanation that links different social and cultural attitudes to the changing reception of vaccination and to debates over compulsion, supported throughout by precise and relevant detail.10-12
- Indicative content:
- Fears about safety and misunderstanding of how vaccination worked led many to reject Jennerian ideas at first, and rumours or isolated adverse events fed public unease.
- Religious objections, including discomfort with using material from animals and beliefs about interfering with divine providence, underpinned some opposition and made persuasion harder.
- Distrust of government interference, and a strong belief in individual liberty, meant that compulsory measures provoked organised resistance and political debate, contributing to the establishment of anti-vaccination societies.
- Conversely, changing attitudes about the role of government in protecting public health, and growing acceptance of empirical medical evidence, gradually made compulsory schemes politically possible in some periods, though they remained contested.
- The role of medical practitioners and local authorities mattered, since trusted local doctors could persuade some people, while heavy-handed central enforcement could inflame resistance.
- A balanced answer weighs how social attitudes shaped both public behaviour and the political feasibility of compulsion, using specific examples such as the 19th-century anti-vaccination movement and later legal compromises.
Question 10
- Level 1 Demonstrates limited knowledge of the period and offers a simple, unsupported opinion on the statement.1-4
- Level 2 Shows some relevant knowledge and offers a basic argument for and against the statement, with limited supporting detail.5-8
- Level 3 Shows good relevant knowledge and develops a balanced argument considering attitudes alongside individuals and scientific developments, supported by accurate detail.9-12
- Level 4 Provides a well-developed, balanced and analytical answer that assesses the relative importance of attitudes, individuals and scientific discoveries, supported throughout by precise and relevant historical detail and clear reasoning.13-16
- Indicative content:
- Arguments supporting the statement, for example that religious conservatism and deference to Galen prevented dissection and new anatomy before c1500, and public or professional resistance delayed acceptance of Jenner, Lister and other innovations.
- Arguments against the statement, for example that individuals such as Vesalius, Harvey, Jenner, Nightingale and Lister used evidence, skill and leadership to overcome hostile attitudes, and that scientific discoveries such as germ theory provided the explanation and technique needed for change.
- How attitudes interacted with other factors: sometimes attitudes slowed adoption even when discovery existed, and sometimes changing evidence or strong individual leadership shifted attitudes in turn.
- Specific examples to discuss: the split between university Galenists and Vesalius's challengers; the anti-vaccination movement and the politics of compulsion; Nightingale's use of public opinion and statistics to press for reforms; the Public Health Act 1875 as a product of changing social attitudes and political will.
- A strong answer reaches a balanced judgement that recognises attitudes as a crucial factor that could enable or block change, but also that individuals and scientific development were often necessary to create the conditions in which attitudes would shift.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.