Life Cycle Assessment, Recycling and Corrosion - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
15 original exam-style questions - 9 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Life Cycle Assessment, Recycling and Corrosion revision guideMore GCSE Science practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 7 of GCSE Chemistry Topic Workbook 4.
2.31 Life Cycle Assessment, Recycling and Corrosion
Table 1
| Alloy | Main metals mixed | Property |
|---|---|---|
| Bronze | copper and tin | hard and resistant to corrosion by seawater |
| Brass | copper and zinc | harder than copper, resists corrosion, has an attractive gold colour |
| Low carbon steel | iron with a small amount of carbon | quite soft and easily shaped |
| High carbon steel | iron with a larger amount of carbon | very hard, but brittle |
Table 2
| Item | CO2e produced during manufacture (kg) |
|---|---|
| Reusable stainless steel bottle (one bottle, lasts several years) | 5.8 |
| Single-use plastic bottle (one bottle) | 0.20 |
Evaluate the extent to which life cycle assessments, such as this one, can be considered fully objective and reliable when comparing the environmental impact of different products.
Tube 1: water that has been boiled (to remove dissolved oxygen), with a layer of oil floating on top of the water.
Tube 2: tap water that has not been boiled, left open to the air.
Tube 3: anhydrous calcium chloride (a drying agent) surrounding the nail, in a stoppered tube containing dry air.
Tube 4: salt water, left open to the air.
He examines the nails after one week.
Question 1
- (a) to compare the environmental impact of different possible designs or materials oeB1
- (a) to identify which stage of the product's life has the greatest environmental impact, so that stage can be targeted for improvement oe (accept: to support evidence-based environmental/marketing claims)B1
- (a) Answer: Any two of: to compare the environmental impact of different designs/materials; to identify which life-cycle stage has the greatest impact so it can be improved; to support evidence-based environmental claims
Question 2
- (a) use a thinner/lighter bottle design that needs less plastic oe (accept: sell water in larger bottles instead of several small ones)B1
- (a) Answer: Use a thinner or lighter bottle design that needs less plastic (or sell water in larger bottles instead of several small ones)
- (b) design the bottle so it can be refilled and used again, e.g. at a water fountain, rather than being thrown away after one use oeB1
- (b) Answer: Design the bottle so it can be refilled and used again, for example at a water fountain, rather than thrown away after one use
- (c) collect used bottles and melt/process the plastic to manufacture new bottles or other plastic products oeB1
- (c) Answer: Collect used bottles and melt down and process the plastic to manufacture new bottles or other plastic products
Question 3
- (a) it conserves the limited/finite amount of metal ore in the Earth oe (accept: reduces the amount of quarrying/mining needed)B1
- (a) it uses much less energy than extracting the same amount of new metal from its ore oe (accept: reduces CO2 emissions, or reduces waste sent to landfill)B1
- (a) Answer: Any two of: conserves finite metal ores; uses much less energy than extracting new metal from ore; reduces CO2 emissions; reduces landfill waste
Question 4
- (a) any valid barrier method, e.g. painting; oiling/greasing; coating with plastic oeB1
- (a) Answer: Any valid barrier method, e.g. painting, oiling/greasing, or coating with plastic
- (b) it forms a physical coating/layer over the surface of the metal oeB1
- (b) this stops oxygen and water from reaching the iron/steel underneath, so rusting cannot occur oeB1
- (b) Answer: It forms a coating over the surface of the metal, which stops oxygen and water from reaching the iron/steel underneath, so rusting cannot occur
Question 5
- (a) pure iron consists of atoms that are all the same size, arranged in regular layers oeB1
- (a) these layers can slide over each other relatively easily, allowing the metal to bend/be shaped oeB1
- (a) Answer: Pure iron atoms are all the same size and arranged in regular layers, which can slide over each other easily, so the metal bends/shapes easily
- (b) the chromium and nickel atoms are a different size to the iron atoms oeB1
- (b) this distorts the regular layers of atoms, making it more difficult for the layers to slide over each other, so the alloy is harder oeB1
- (b) Answer: The chromium and nickel atoms are a different size to the iron atoms, which distorts the regular layers and makes it harder for them to slide over each other, so the alloy is harder
Question 6
- (a) bronze caoB1
- (a) because it is hard and resists corrosion by seawater oeB1
- (a) Answer: Bronze, because it is hard and resists corrosion by seawater
- (b) high carbon steel caoB1
- (b) because it is very hard, so it can hold a sharp cutting edge oeB1
- (b) Answer: High carbon steel, because it is very hard, so it can hold a sharp cutting edge
Question 7
- (a) the exact composition of the mixed scrap is not known or uniform, so the properties of the alloy recycled from it cannot be accurately controlled oeB1
- (a) different metals/alloys may need to be separated (e.g. by density or using magnets) before recycling, which adds cost and complexity oeB1
- (a) Answer: The exact composition of mixed scrap is not known or uniform, so the properties of the recycled alloy cannot be controlled; the different metals may also need to be separated first, adding cost and complexity
- (b) using a strong magnet/electromagnet to attract and remove the steel oeB1
- (b) Answer: Using a strong magnet (or electromagnet) to attract and remove the steel
Question 8
- (a) recycling glass uses less energy than manufacturing new glass, because crushed recycled glass melts at a lower temperature than the raw materials oeB1
- (a) using less energy reduces the amount of fossil fuel burned, which reduces carbon dioxide emissions oeB1
- (a) recycling conserves the finite/limited raw materials (e.g. sand, limestone) needed to make new glass oeB1
- (a) recycling reduces the amount of glass waste sent to landfill oe (any two developed advantages, up to 2 marks each, for full marks)B1
- (a) Answer: Any two developed advantages, e.g. recycling uses less energy (crushed glass melts at a lower temperature), reducing CO2 emissions; and recycling conserves finite raw materials such as sand and limestone, and reduces landfill waste
Question 9
- (a) 30 x 0.20 oeM1
- (a) 6 kg caoA1
- (a) Answer: 6 kg CO2e
- (b) 5.8 / 0.20 oeM1
- (b) = 29, so the CO2e saved would exactly equal (not exceed) the reusable bottle's manufacturing footprint at 29 bottles avoided oeM1
- (b) 30 (bottles) caoA1
- (b) Answer: 30 bottles
- (c) any valid factor, e.g. the energy/water used to wash and refill the reusable bottle; the impact of disposing of the bottles at the end of their life (e.g. recycling versus landfill); the energy used to transport the bottles oeB1
- (c) Answer: Any valid factor, e.g. the energy and water used to wash and refill the reusable bottle, or the environmental impact of disposal at the end of each bottle's life
Question 10
- Level 3 A detailed and coherent evaluation that discusses both the quantifiable (numerical) aspects of an LCA and the aspects that require value judgements or are difficult to measure, with clear links between them and a reasoned conclusion about objectivity. The answer is logically structured throughout, using scientific terminology accurately.5-6
- Level 2 Relevant points about the objective (quantifiable) and/or subjective (value-judgement) aspects of an LCA are given, with some explanation, but the discussion is not fully balanced or the conclusion is not fully justified. The answer has some structure.3-4
- Level 1 Basic or isolated statements are given, for example simply stating that LCAs are useful or that they can be biased, with little or no explanation or supporting reasoning.1-2
- Level 0 No relevant content.0
- Indicative content:
- Objective/quantifiable aspects: factors such as energy use, water use and CO2 emissions during manufacture, transport and disposal can be measured and compared numerically, giving the LCA an objective, evidence-based element.
- Subjective aspects: some environmental impacts, e.g. the effect of litter on wildlife, habitat damage from mining/quarrying, or the visual impact of waste, are difficult to measure numerically and require value judgements about their relative importance, introducing subjectivity.
- Assumptions and system boundaries: different assumptions made when carrying out the LCA, e.g. the system boundary chosen, assumed transport distances, or the assumed method of disposal/recycling rate, can significantly change the result, so two LCAs of the same products could reach different conclusions.
- Possible bias: because the LCA was commissioned by the manufacturer, there is a risk of selective use of data, or of the assessment being used to support a conclusion that favours the manufacturer's own product or commercial interests (sometimes called greenwashing).
- Reliability: a fully reliable and unbiased LCA requires independent verification and full transparency about the assumptions and data sources used.
- Conclusion: LCAs provide useful, partly quantitative evidence for comparing products, but they are not fully objective, because some factors cannot be reliably quantified and must be judged, and the party commissioning the LCA may introduce bias.
Question 11
- (a) moles of N2 = 28 / 28 = 1 (using tonnes as the mass unit) oeM1
- (a) mole ratio of N2 : NH3 is 1 : 2, so moles of NH3 = 2 oeM1
- (a) mass of NH3 = 2 x 17 = 34 tonnes caoA1
- (a) Answer: 34 tonnes
- (b) 34 x 0.15 oe, ft from (a)M1
- (b) 5.1 tonnes caoA1
- (b) Answer: 5.1 tonnes
Question 12
- (a) crops remove nutrients (nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium compounds) from the soil as they grow oeB1
- (a) fertilisers replace these nutrients, allowing higher crop yields/healthier growth in future crops oeB1
- (a) Answer: Crops remove nutrients from the soil as they grow; fertilisers replace these nutrients, allowing higher yields and healthier growth in future crops
- (b) phosphate rock is treated/reacted with an acid oeB1
- (b) e.g. treating it with nitric acid, sulfuric acid or phosphoric acid oeB1
- (b) this produces soluble calcium phosphate salts, such as single superphosphate or triple superphosphate, that plant roots can absorb oeB1
- (b) Answer: Phosphate rock is treated with an acid, such as nitric acid, sulfuric acid or phosphoric acid, to produce soluble calcium phosphate salts (e.g. single or triple superphosphate) that plants can absorb
- (c) (i) ammonia/ammonium compounds (e.g. ammonium nitrate) produced by the Haber process oeB1
- (c) (ii) phosphate rock (treated with acid) oeB1
- (c) (iii) potassium chloride or potassium sulfate, mined from underground deposits oeB1
- (c) Answer: (i) Ammonia/ammonium compounds from the Haber process. (ii) Phosphate rock. (iii) Potassium chloride or potassium sulfate, mined from underground deposits
Question 13
- (a) Mr of NH4NO3 = 14 + (4 x 1) + 14 + (3 x 16) = 80 oeM1
- (a) total mass of N in the formula = 14 + 14 = 28 oeM1
- (a) % N = 28 / 80 x 100 = 35% caoA1
- (a) Answer: 35%
- (b) 25 x 0.35 oe, ft from (a)M1
- (b) 8.75 kg caoA1
- (b) Answer: 8.75 kg
Question 14
- (a) the conditions/substances that each iron nail is exposed to (e.g. presence of water, oxygen or salt) oeB1
- (a) Answer: The conditions each iron nail is exposed to (whether water, oxygen and/or salt are present)
- (b) any sensible control variable, e.g. same size/type of iron nail used in each tube; same time period before the nails are examined oeB1
- (b) Answer: Any sensible control variable, e.g. using the same size and type of iron nail in each tube, and examining them after the same time period
- (c) Tube 1 identifiedB1
- (c) boiling removes dissolved oxygen from the water, and the oil layer stops more oxygen dissolving into the water, so oxygen is not available (even though water is present) oeB1
- (c) Tube 3 identifiedB1
- (c) the calcium chloride keeps the air inside the tube dry, so water/moisture is not available (even though oxygen is present) oeB1
- (c) Answer: Tube 1 (boiled water with an oil layer, so no oxygen is present) and Tube 3 (dry air with a drying agent, so no water is present) would show little or no rusting, because rusting needs both oxygen and water together
- (d) Tube 4 (salt water, open to the air) identifiedB1
- (d) this tube contains both dissolved oxygen (from the air) and water, and the dissolved salt speeds up the rusting process oeB1
- (d) Answer: Tube 4 (the salt water tube), because it contains both oxygen and water, and the dissolved salt increases the rate of rusting
- (e) weigh each nail before the experiment and again after, and calculate the change (or percentage change) in mass oeB1
- (e) set up each condition in duplicate/triplicate (repeat each condition more than once) oeB1
- (e) repeats allow a mean to be calculated and anomalous results to be identified, making the conclusion more reliable oeB1
- (e) Answer: Weigh each nail before and after the experiment to calculate the change in mass (a numerical measure of rusting); repeating each condition allows a mean to be calculated and anomalies to be spotted, making the results more reliable
- (f) paint acts as a barrier, keeping oxygen and water away from the surface of the iron oeB1
- (f) links to the investigation: Tubes 1 and 3 show that removing either oxygen or water alone stops rusting, so keeping both away is effective oeB1
- (f) if the paint is scratched, the exposed iron is in contact with oxygen and water again, so it can start to rust at that point oeB1
- (f) Answer: Paint forms a barrier that keeps oxygen and water away from the iron surface; since the investigation shows removing either substance prevents rusting, this barrier is effective, but if the paint is scratched the exposed iron can rust again
- (g) barrier method/barrier protection oeB1
- (g) Answer: Barrier method (barrier protection)
Question 15
- (a) magnesium is more reactive than iron oeB1
- (a) so magnesium loses electrons/corrodes in preference to (instead of) the iron, protecting the steel pipeline oeB1
- (a) Answer: Magnesium is more reactive than iron, so it corrodes instead of the iron, protecting the steel pipeline
- (b) the magnesium blocks gradually corrode away/are used up as they protect the pipeline oeB1
- (b) once a block has completely corroded away, it can no longer protect the steel, so the pipeline would then start to corrode oeB1
- (b) Answer: The magnesium blocks gradually corrode away as they protect the pipeline; once a block is fully used up it can no longer protect the steel, so it must be replaced
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.