Chromatography and Instrumental Analysis
Chromatography is a technique used to separate the substances in a mixture and to help identify them, based on how strongly each substance is attracted to a mobile phase, the solvent moving through the paper, compared with a stationary phase, the paper itself. Paper chromatography results are interpreted by calculating the Rf value of a spot, while instrumental methods such as gas chromatography linked to mass spectrometry (GC-MS) give faster, more sensitive analysis for Higher tier.
Method
- Set up the experiment correctly: draw a pencil baseline near the bottom of the chromatography paper (pencil is used because it does not dissolve in the solvent or react, unlike ink), add small spots of each sample on the baseline, and stand the paper in a shallow layer of solvent that is below the level of the baseline, so the samples do not dissolve straight into the solvent.
- Explain the separation: as the solvent (the mobile phase) travels up the paper by capillary action, each substance in a spot distributes between the solvent and the paper (the stationary phase); a substance that is more soluble in the solvent spends more time in the mobile phase and travels further up the paper, while a substance more strongly attracted to the paper travels less far.
- Calculate the Rf value for a spot using Rf = distance travelled by the substance divided by distance travelled by the solvent, both measured from the baseline; every Rf value is between 0 and 1, since a spot can never travel further than the solvent front.
- Use the number of spots to judge purity: a pure substance produces exactly one spot on the chromatogram, however many different solvents are tried, while a mixture usually separates into two or more spots.
- Identify unknown substances either by comparing their Rf value with published reference values for the same solvent, or, more reliably, by running known reference substances on the same plate alongside the unknown and comparing spot positions and Rf values directly under identical conditions.
- For Higher tier, explain the advantages of instrumental methods of analysis over manual tests: they tend to be much more sensitive (able to detect very small amounts of a substance), more accurate, and faster, though they need calibrating against samples of known concentration.
- For Higher tier, describe gas chromatography linked to mass spectrometry (GC-MS): gas chromatography separates a mixture into its individual components, each leaving the column at its own characteristic retention time; the mass spectrum recorded for each component shows a molecular ion peak whose mass to charge ratio gives the relative molecular mass of that compound, helping to identify it.
Common mistakes
MistakeMeasuring the distance a spot has travelled from the solvent front rather than from the baseline, giving a value the Rf formula does not need.
InsteadBoth distances in the Rf formula start from the same point, the pencil baseline: measure from the baseline up to the spot, and separately from the baseline up to the solvent front, then divide the first by the second.
MistakeBelieving a chromatogram with only one spot must always be a pure substance, even when only one solvent has been tried.
InsteadOne spot in a single solvent only shows that the substances present travelled together in that particular solvent; a genuine test of purity needs several different solvents, since two different substances can coincidentally share an Rf value in one solvent but not in another.
MistakeAssuming a higher Rf value always means the substance is 'more pure' or 'better', rather than just a measure of how far it travelled relative to the solvent, which depends on the solvent and paper used.
InsteadRf is not a mark of quality; it only shows how strongly a substance is attracted to the mobile phase compared with the stationary phase for a specific solvent and paper. The same substance gives different Rf values in different solvents, so Rf alone says nothing about purity.
Worked examples
Example 1
A student runs a paper chromatogram of an ink mixture. The solvent front has travelled 9.0 cm from the baseline. The ink separates into two spots, A and B. Spot A has travelled 3.6 cm and spot B has travelled 7.2 cm. Calculate the Rf value of each spot, and state what the two spots show about the ink.
- Write the Rf formula: Rf = distance travelled by the spot / distance travelled by the solvent.
- Calculate Rf for spot A: 3.6 / 9.0 = 0.4.
- Calculate Rf for spot B: 7.2 / 9.0 = 0.8.
- Interpret the two spots: since the ink separates into two spots with different Rf values, the ink is a mixture of at least two different coloured substances, not a pure single dye.
- Final answer: Rf(A) = 0.4 and Rf(B) = 0.8, and the two spots show the ink is a mixture of two components.
Example 2
A sample believed to be an alcohol is analysed by GC-MS. It leaves the gas chromatography column as a single peak, and its mass spectrum shows a molecular ion peak at m/z = 46. Given that ethanol has the molecular formula C2H6O and propan-1-ol has the molecular formula C3H8O, use relative atomic masses (C = 12, H = 1, O = 16) to determine which of the two alcohols the sample is.
- Recall that the molecular ion peak's mass to charge ratio (m/z) equals the relative molecular mass of the whole, unfragmented molecule.
- Calculate the relative formula mass of ethanol, C2H6O: (2 x 12) + (6 x 1) + 16 = 46.
- Calculate the relative formula mass of propan-1-ol, C3H8O: (3 x 12) + (8 x 1) + 16 = 60.
- Compare both values with the measured molecular ion peak, m/z = 46: this matches ethanol's Mr, not propan-1-ol's.
- Final answer: the sample is ethanol, C2H6O (Mr = 46).
Practice questions
Q1[1 mark]Write the formula for calculating an Rf value.Show answer
Answer: Rf = distance travelled by the substance (spot) / distance travelled by the solvent, both measured from the baseline.
Q2[2 marks]In a chromatography experiment, a dye spot travels 4.5 cm and the solvent front travels 6.0 cm. Calculate its Rf value.Show answer
Answer: 0.75 (4.5 / 6.0).
Q3[4 marks]Explain why the baseline is drawn in pencil rather than ink.Show answer
Answer: Pencil marks are insoluble in the solvent and do not react with it, so the baseline stays fixed; ink would dissolve into the solvent and run with the samples, making the results unreliable.
Q4[3 marks]Explain why the solvent level in the container must be below the pencil baseline.Show answer
Answer: If the solvent covered the baseline, the sample spots would dissolve directly into the bulk solvent rather than being carried up the paper, so no separation would take place.
Q5[1 mark]A sample produces only one spot when run in three different solvents. What does this suggest about the sample?Show answer
Answer: It suggests the sample is a pure substance rather than a mixture, since a mixture would be expected to separate into more than one spot in at least one solvent.
Q6[1 mark]State one advantage of running known reference substances alongside an unknown sample on the same chromatogram, rather than only comparing to published Rf values.Show answer
Answer: The reference and the unknown experience exactly the same paper, solvent, temperature and distance travelled by the solvent, so their spot positions can be compared directly and reliably, whereas published Rf values can vary between different experimental conditions.
Q7[2 marks]State two advantages of instrumental methods of analysis, such as GC-MS, compared with manual chemical tests.Show answer
Answer: They are generally more sensitive, able to detect very small quantities, and faster; they can also be more accurate than manual tests, though they must be calibrated against known standards.
Exam-style questions
Written in the style of a GCSE Science exam paper, with a full mark scheme.
Exam tips
- Give Rf values to 2 decimal places, or as an exact simplified fraction, and always compare them under identical conditions: temperature, solvent and paper must be the same for a reference and an unknown to be compared validly.
- For a 'which dyes are present' chromatography question, state the Rf value or the matching distance for each dye you rule in and each you rule out, not just the ones you conclude are present.
- For a GC-MS explain question, give both halves separately: what the retention time from the gas chromatography stage tells you, and what the molecular ion peak's m/z from the mass spectrum tells you, since each is usually worth its own mark.
Q1[6 marks]A student wants to find out which of four food dyes, labelled P, Q, R and S, are present in a green sweet coating. She runs a paper chromatogram with a spot of the sweet coating extract and a spot of each of the four reference dyes, using the same solvent for all five spots. The solvent front travels 10.0 cm. The sweet coating extract produces two spots, at 3.0 cm and 8.0 cm from the baseline. Reference dye P travels 3.0 cm, Q travels 5.0 cm, R travels 8.0 cm and S travels 9.0 cm. Explain how the student can identify which dyes are in the sweet coating, and state which dyes she should conclude are present.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 6 available
Q2[3 marks]Explain why gas chromatography linked to mass spectrometry (GC-MS) can identify individual components in a mixture more reliably than paper chromatography alone.Show mark scheme
Tick each line you got.
Nothing ticked yet - 3 available
See real GCSE Science past-paper questions, with official mark schemes
This topic in real past papers
We have tagged some boards' past papers question by question (not every board or year yet). This topic comes up in:
- OCR GCSE Chemistry past papers: 36 questions across 16 papers, latest tagged June 2024
- OCR GCSE Combined Science past papers: 24 questions across 19 papers, latest tagged June 2024
- WJEC GCSE Chemistry past papers: 12 questions across 10 papers, latest tagged Summer 2024
- AQA GCSE Chemistry past papers: 9 questions across 8 papers, latest tagged June 2023
- AQA GCSE Combined Science past papers: 7 questions across 7 papers, latest tagged June 2023
- WJEC GCSE Combined Science past papers: 5 questions across 5 papers, latest tagged Summer 2024
Free printable worksheet
Want more practice on paper? Download the Chromatography and Instrumental Analysis worksheet pack - 10 pages of exam-style questions with a full mark scheme. Free to download, no card or account. Print it for personal and classroom use.
This topic is chapter 16 of GCSE Chemistry Essentials, the whole course as one free printable PDF. Its worksheet is also chapter 1 of GCSE Chemistry Topic Workbook 4 and chapter 24 of GCSE Chemistry 10-Minute Tests, free printable practice books.
Other versions of this worksheet: