Interviews: Structured, Unstructured and Group - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
12 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Interviews: Structured, Unstructured and Group revision guideMore GCSE Sociology practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 12 of GCSE Sociology Topic Workbook 1 and chapter 12 of GCSE Sociology 10-Minute Tests 1.
2.4 Interviews: Structured, Unstructured and Group
- A) questionnaire
- B) structured interview
- C) covert observation
- D) official statistic
Question 1
- identifies a more reciprocal style as the interviewer being willing to answer the interviewee's questions and share something of themselves, rather than remaining a detached, neutral questionerB1
- development, e.g. Oakley argued this built the trust and rapport needed for women to talk openly about sensitive experiences such as childbirthB1
- Answer: A more reciprocal interviewing style involves the interviewer being willing to answer the interviewee's own questions and share something of themselves, rather than remaining a detached, neutral questioner. Oakley argued this built the trust and rapport needed for women to talk openly about sensitive experiences such as childbirth.
Question 2
- identifies a genuine criticism, e.g. the closer relationship it creates between interviewer and interviewee can reduce objectivityB1
- development, e.g. it can also make it harder to ask the same questions in a standardised way across interviews, reducing reliabilityB1
- Answer: Critics argue the closer relationship a reciprocal interviewing style creates between interviewer and interviewee can reduce objectivity, and can make it harder to ask questions in a standardised way across interviews, reducing reliability.
Question 3
- identifies the first stage as a structured interview (fixed questions, same order for every pupil)B1
- identifies its result: short, guarded answers, suggesting lower validity on this sensitive topicB1
- identifies the second stage as an unstructured interview (informal, conversational, with follow-up questions)B1
- identifies its result: longer, more detailed accounts, including unexpected new informationB1
- explains why: the flexible, rapport-building nature of unstructured interviews can generate richer, more valid data on a sensitive topic like bullyingB1
- accurate use of terminology throughout (structured/unstructured interview, validity, rapport)B1
- Answer: The first stage is a structured interview, which produces short, guarded answers, suggesting lower validity on this sensitive topic. The second stage is an unstructured interview, which produces longer, more detailed accounts, including unexpected new information, because its flexible, rapport-building nature generates richer, more valid data on a sensitive topic like bullying.
Question 4
- Level 4 A detailed, well-balanced evaluation that accurately explains BOTH the case for unstructured interviews' validity AND the case for structured interviews' reliability, supported by accurate reference to Ann Oakley's work. Strengths and weaknesses of each are analysed, and a reasoned, supported judgement is reached. Sociological terminology is used accurately and consistently throughout.10-12
- Level 3 A clear evaluation that explains both the unstructured-interview case and the structured-interview case, with some accurate detail. Some analysis of strengths/weaknesses. An attempt at a conclusion, which may be only partly supported.7-9
- Level 2 Some relevant explanation of interview types, with limited development or accuracy. Little clear evaluation or comparison of views.4-6
- Level 1 One or two isolated, undeveloped points about interviews, with little or no sociological terminology or accurate detail.1-3
- Level 0 No relevant content.0
- Indicative content:
- Case for unstructured interviews: their flexibility allows follow-up questions and probing, generating richer, more valid data, especially on sensitive topics.
- Case continued: Ann Oakley argued a more reciprocal, rapport-building style, as opposed to the detached traditional model, produces more honest, meaningful answers, particularly researching women's experiences.
- Case for structured interviews: standardised questions asked in the same way and order make results reliable, comparable and repeatable, favoured by the positivist tradition.
- Case continued: structured interviews are quicker to administer and analyse across a large sample, and reduce interviewer bias compared with a more free-flowing conversation.
- Evaluation of unstructured interviews: critics argue the closer, less standardised approach reduces objectivity and makes it harder to compare answers across interviews, reducing reliability.
- Evaluation of structured interviews: critics argue fixed questions cannot capture unexpected information or the true depth of an interviewee's meaning, reducing validity, particularly on sensitive topics.
- A balanced conclusion should weigh unstructured interviews' strength in validity and depth against structured interviews' strength in reliability and scale, noting the choice often depends on the sensitivity of the topic and the researcher's theoretical approach.
Question 5
- identifies reliability as the extent to which a research method, if repeated by another researcher in the same way, would produce the same or consistent resultsB1
- development, e.g. this tends to be higher for structured interviews than for unstructured interviewsB1
- Answer: Reliability is the extent to which a research method, if repeated by another researcher in the same way, would produce the same or consistent results; this tends to be higher for structured interviews than for unstructured interviews.
Question 6
- identifies that every respondent is asked identical, standardised questions in the same order and wayB1
- development, e.g. so the interview can be repeated exactly and results can be checked or comparedB1
- Answer: Because every respondent is asked identical, standardised questions in the same order and way, a structured interview can be repeated exactly by another researcher, so results can be checked or compared.
Question 7
- sums the 20 values correctly: total = 69B1
- calculates the mean = 69 / 20 = 3.45 (awrt 3.5) themes per interviewB1
- compares this to the structured interviews' fixed 3 themes, identifying the unstructured interviews generated on average more distinct themes (3.45 vs 3)B1
- links this to validity: unstructured interviews, by letting respondents raise topics not asked about directly, can produce richer, more valid dataB1
- Answer: Total = 69, mean = 69 / 20 = 3.45 themes per unstructured interview, slightly more than the fixed 3 themes covered in each structured interview. This suggests the unstructured format let respondents raise additional issues, producing richer, more valid data.
Question 8
- identifies a genuine reason, e.g. the unstructured interviews were likely much longer, giving more time and opportunity for extra themes to come upB1
- brief development, e.g. so the difference may partly reflect interview length rather than the structured/unstructured format aloneB1
- Answer: The unstructured interviews were likely much longer than the structured ones, giving more time and opportunity for extra themes to come up, so the difference may partly reflect interview length rather than the structured/unstructured format alone.
Question 9
- (a) identifies the structured interview as using fixed questions asked in a fixed order, like a questionnaire read aloudB1
- (a) identifies the unstructured interview as informal and conversational, with few or no pre-set questions, following the interviewee's responsesB1
- (a) Answer: A structured interview uses fixed questions asked in a fixed order, like a questionnaire read aloud, while an unstructured interview is informal and conversational, with few or no pre-set questions, following the interviewee's own responses.
- (b) identifies that both use standardised, pre-set questions asked in the same way of every respondentB1
- (b) development, e.g. interviewer/researcher effect is minimised in both compared with unstructured methodsB1
- (b) Answer: Both a structured interview and a questionnaire use standardised, pre-set questions asked in the same way of every respondent, minimising the interviewer effect compared with unstructured methods.
Question 10
- identifies a first strength, e.g. flexibility to follow up interesting answers and probe deeperB1
- development, e.g. generating richer, more valid data than a fixed set of questionsB1
- identifies a second strength, e.g. better able to build rapport and trust with the intervieweeB1
- development, e.g. useful when researching sensitive topicsB1
- Answer: Unstructured interviews offer the flexibility to follow up interesting answers and probe deeper, generating richer, more valid data than a fixed set of questions. They are also better able to build rapport and trust with the interviewee, which is especially useful when researching sensitive topics.
Question 11
- identifies a genuine advantage, e.g. they are quicker to administer, with less need to train interviewers, and quicker to analyseB1
- brief developmentB1
- Answer: Structured interviews are quicker to administer, with less need to train interviewers, and quicker to analyse, since responses are standardised, making them practical for a large sample and limited time.
Question 12
- B (structured interview)B1
- Answer: B
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.