Worked question 9 - Quality Management: Total Quality Management and Cost of Quality
Answer and mark scheme
Question 9
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| B1 | identifies relevant facts from the data, e.g. there are many more internal faults (1,200) than returns (300), and external failure costs are large (£4,500) |
| B1 | explains that internal faults indicate production problems that, if fixed, can reduce both appraisal and external failure costs |
| B1 | explains that external returns cost BrightBrew directly £4,500 and risk harming reputation, so reducing returns has high priority |
| B1 | applies cost figures to argue where marginal gains are larger, e.g. cutting returns saves external failure costs directly whereas reducing internal faults can also lower inspection/rework |
| B1 | analyses trade-offs, e.g. investing more in training or process changes (prevention) may increase prevention costs but reduce larger external failure costs over time |
| B1 | analyses short-term vs long-term priorities, e.g. quick wins might be improved inspection or targeted fixes to reduce immediate returns, while TQM style prevention is a longer term investment |
| B1 | considers capacity and cost-effectiveness, e.g. given training is 1,500 and inspection 2,000, reallocating some of that to prevention actions could be justified if it reduces the 4,500 external cost |
| B1 | draws a reasoned conclusion about priorities, e.g. focus first on causes of returns while planning prevention measures to reduce internal faults and long-term external costs |
- Answer: The data show many more internal faults (1,200) than customer returns (300), but external failure costs are high at £4,500 per month. This suggests BrightBrew should prioritise actions that reduce returns because each return creates direct cost and reputational risk, giving an immediate benefit. However internal faults are the root cause and fixing them through prevention (training or process changes) can reduce both appraisal costs and external failure costs over time. Investment in prevention increases short-term prevention costs but can be justified if it reduces the larger external costs. A balanced approach is sensible: short-term targeted fixes to cut returns quickly while implementing prevention measures, such as quality circles, to reduce internal faults and lower total monthly quality costs in the longer term.



