Worked question 15 - Choropleth Maps
| Region | Ashcombe | Bramwell | Corfe | Dunley | Elmsgate | Foxmere |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Recycling rate (%) | 38 | 51 | 44 | 29 | 60 | 47 |
The journalist must decide whether to publish this information as a choropleth map or as a table of the exact percentages.
Evaluate which representation would be more appropriate for this article, referring to the audience and the purpose of the article in your answer.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 15
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| 1-2 | Level 1 Makes a simple, largely unsupported choice, e.g. states one feature of a map or a table with little or no link to the audience or purpose of the article. |
| 3-4 | Level 2 Gives a reasoned comparison referring to at least one relevant factor (e.g. the general readership, wanting a quick visual impression, or wanting precise figures), but the argument is one-sided or not fully developed. |
| 5-6 | Level 3 Gives a sustained, balanced evaluation that weighs the needs of a general public audience against the purpose of a short online article, reaching a justified overall recommendation while acknowledging a limitation of the chosen representation. |
- Indicative content:
- A choropleth map lets a general reader see at a glance which regions recycle more or less, without needing to compare numbers.
- A table gives the exact recycling rate for every region, which is more precise but requires more effort from a casual reader to interpret.
- A short newspaper article is aimed at a general audience who are unlikely to want to study exact figures; a quick visual summary better suits the purpose.
- A choropleth map could still be supported by quoting a few key figures in the text (e.g. the highest and lowest region), without needing a full table.
- A disadvantage of the map is that within-band differences (e.g. Bramwell 51% and Foxmere 47%, if shaded the same band) would not be visible to the reader.
- A well-justified conclusion in either direction should be credited, provided it is supported by reference to the audience and/or the purpose of the article.
Answer: Exemplar recommendation: the choropleth map is likely more appropriate for this article, since it suits the general audience and purpose of showing a quick regional pattern, though the highest and lowest region's exact figures could still be quoted in the text.











