Worked question 10 - Comparing Data Sets
Lower reaction times mean faster responses; a smaller range means less spread in this sample. Using all six observations, Under 16s have a mean of 215.5 ms and a range of 42 ms, while Adults have a mean of 200 ms and a range of 130 ms. The question asks for the adult mean and range again without 300 ms: the mean is 180 ms and the range is 20 ms. This shows how sensitive the comparison is to that high observation. Its size alone does not show that it was a recording error, and these figures describe only the supplied samples.
Under 16s: 210, 225, 198, 240, 215, 205
Adults: 180, 175, 190, 185, 170, 300
Answer and mark scheme
Question 10
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| B1 | (a) names a suitable sampling method (e.g. random sampling, or stratified sampling by age group) |
| B1 | (a) gives a valid reason (e.g. avoids bias in who is chosen, so the two samples can be fairly compared), oe |
| B1 | (b) Under 16s mean = 215.5 ms |
| B1 | (b) Under 16s range = 42 ms |
| B1 | (b) Adults mean = 200 ms |
| B1 | (b) Adults range = 130 ms |
| B1 | (c) identifies the value as an outlier |
| B1 | (c) new mean = 180 ms |
| B1 | (c) new range = 20 ms |
| B1 | (d) recognises the Under 16s figures (mean 215.5 ms, range 42 ms) are not affected by an outlier and are representative of that group |
| B1 | (d) concludes that, once the outlier is removed, the Adults reacted faster (180 ms vs 215.5 ms) and more consistently (range 20 ms vs 42 ms) than the Under 16s, so the original Adults data was misleading, oe |
- (a) Answer: Use random sampling within each age group (e.g. numbering participants and using a random number generator).
- (b) Answer: Under 16s: mean 215.5 ms, range 42 ms. Adults: mean 200 ms, range 130 ms.
- (c) Answer: 300 ms is an outlier; without it, mean = 180 ms and range = 20 ms.
- (d) Answer: Once the outlier is removed, Adults reacted faster and more consistently than Under 16s.











