Explanations for Obedience: Agentic State and Legitimacy of Authority - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
14 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Explanations for Obedience: Agentic State and Legitimacy of Authority revision guideWrite-in editionMore A Level Psychology practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 3 of A Level Psychology Topic Workbook 1 and chapter 3 of A Level Psychology 10-Minute Tests 1.
1.2 Explanations for Obedience: Agentic State and Legitimacy of Authority
Question 1
- states that authority can be destructive when a legitimate figure uses their power to order harmful or immoral acts, and followers obey because of that perceived legitimacy oeB1
- Answer: Legitimate authority becomes destructive when an authority figure uses their recognised power to order harmful or immoral acts, and people obey because they accept the figure's right to command.
Question 2
- states Kilham and Mann found lower levels of obedience to authority than Milgram did in his original US study oeM1
- explains implication: suggests legitimacy of authority effects may vary by culture or social context oeA1
- Answer: Kilham and Mann found lower obedience levels in their Australian replication than reported in Milgram's US work. This suggests that legitimacy of authority may not produce the same levels of obedience in all cultures and that social context can affect how authority is perceived.
Question 3
- outlines key procedural point: participants were instructed by an experimenter to harass a job applicant by giving stressful interview questions in the presence of an authority figure, with confederate responses scripted oeM1
- explains implication: high rates of compliance under an authority indicate people can act as agents under orders, supporting agentic state ideas about shifted responsibility oeA1
- Answer: Meeus and Raaijmakers had participants, under instruction, harass a job applicant with stressful questions; many followed the instructions. The finding supports the agentic state idea that people can carry out harmful acts when acting as agents under authority, transferring responsibility to the authority.
Question 4
- identifies a strength, e.g. the setting was real and the nurses did not know they were being studied, so their behaviour was natural oeM1
- explains the benefit, e.g. this gives high ecological validity and reduces demand characteristics, so the findings are more likely to generalise to real-world obedience oeA1
- Answer: Because the nurses were on their real wards and did not know about the study, they behaved naturally, so the study has high ecological validity and the findings are more likely to apply to real obedience.
Question 5
- identifies a binding factor from the scenario, e.g. the awkwardness of arguing or being seen as disloyal (the cost of disobeying) oeB1
- identifies a sign of moral strain from the scenario, e.g. her hands shaking, or her belief that the act is wrong oeB1
- explains how the binding factor keeps her in the agentic state, e.g. it makes refusing seem more uncomfortable than obeying, so she continues oeB1
- Answer: Binding factor: she wants to avoid an awkward argument and being seen as disloyal, so refusing feels costly. Sign of moral strain: her hands shake while she types (she believes the act is wrong). The binding factor keeps her obeying because disobeying feels more uncomfortable than carrying on.
Question 6
- states that the autonomous state is when an individual acts according to their own conscience and feels personal responsibility for their actions oeB1
- Answer: The autonomous state is when an individual acts according to their own conscience and takes personal responsibility for their actions.
Question 7
- states that legitimacy of authority means people obey those seen as having the right to give orders because their authority is socially agreed oeM1
- states that socially agreed hierarchies (e.g. police, teachers) give those people power to demand obedience oeA1
- Answer: Legitimacy of authority is the idea that people obey those who are perceived as having the right to give orders because society accepts certain hierarchies, for example police and teachers are given power that makes people more likely to follow their instructions.
Question 8
- points out that Kilham and Mann's lower obedience suggests legitimacy of authority effects vary between cultures, challenging universality oeM1
- explains why this matters, e.g. if legitimacy depends on culturally specific acceptance of hierarchies then the explanation lacks cross-cultural generalisability oeA1
- points out Meeus and Raaijmakers show situational factors and the presence of an authority can produce high compliance even without extreme physical harm, supporting agentic state mechanisms oeM1
- explains implication, e.g. situational details and procedures influence whether agency occurs, so explanations must allow for situational moderators rather than claiming simple universality oeA1
- Answer: Kilham and Mann's lower obedience suggests legitimacy of authority may be weaker in some cultures, reducing generalisability. Meeus and Raaijmakers show that situational procedures and authoritative instruction can produce high compliance, supporting agentic mechanisms but indicating that situational details matter. Together they imply the explanations need to account for cultural and procedural moderators.
Question 9
- Level 4 Knowledge of explanations for obedience is accurate, relevant and well detailed. Evaluation is thorough and balanced, considering methodological issues, supporting and challenging evidence, and cross-cultural implications. Argument is well developed and applied to research such as Kilham and Mann and Meeus and Raaijmakers. Specialist terminology is used effectively.10-12
- Level 3 Knowledge of the agentic state and legitimacy of authority is mostly accurate with reasonable detail. Evaluation is present and reasonably developed, with some reference to supporting and opposing evidence including cross-cultural points. Application to named studies is present but may be less detailed.7-9
- Level 2 Basic knowledge of the explanations is present but may be incomplete or partially inaccurate. Evaluation is limited or one-sided, and consideration of cross-cultural evidence is superficial. Answer lacks depth and organisation in places.4-6
- Level 1 Very limited knowledge and understanding. Little or no appropriate evaluation. Answer may be mostly descriptive or disorganised with little use of evidence.1-3
- Level 0 No creditable content.0
- Indicative content:
- AO1: Agentic state: definition, agentic shift from autonomous to agentic state, moral strain experienced when orders conflict with conscience, and binding factors that reduce disobedience such as denying responsibility, focusing on the task, or incremental commitment.
- AO1: Legitimacy of authority: definition, socially agreed hierarchies give certain figures the perceived right to issue orders, and how this can lead to obedience even when orders are immoral; destructive authority where legitimate power is misused.
- AO1: Clear distinction between explanations: agentic state focuses on cognitive shift and perceived responsibility, legitimacy focuses on social structure and perceived right to command.
- AO3: Supportive evidence: research showing high obedience where legitimate authority or clear authority figures are present, including administrative obedience studies such as Meeus and Raaijmakers (1986) supporting agentic processes in an applied setting.
- AO3: Cross-cultural and replication evidence: Kilham and Mann (1974) found lower obedience in Australia than Milgram in the USA, suggesting cultural variation in acceptance of authority and challenging claims of universality; discuss implications for both explanations.
- AO3: Methodological evaluation: many supporting studies use artificial tasks or lab settings, which may affect ecological validity; Meeus and Raaijmakers used an administrative procedure closer to real-life, increasing ecological validity but raising ethical concerns.
- AO3: Alternative explanations and individual differences: dispositional factors such as authoritarian personality or moral reasoning may moderate obedience, and personality can explain why some resist; discuss interactionist views where both situational legitimacy and personal factors matter.
- AO3: Practical implications and ethical considerations: understanding these explanations helps design systems to reduce destructive obedience, e.g. emphasising individual responsibility and checks on authority; ethical critique that some research methods involved distress or deception.
- AO3: Overall evaluation: weigh strengths and limits, argue that both explanations capture important facets of obedience but must be seen as complementary and moderated by culture, context and individual differences.
Question 10
- identifies that a doctor holds a position of legitimate authority in the hospital hierarchy, and nurses are expected to follow doctors' instructions oeM1
- explains that the nurses obeyed even though the caller was unknown and the order broke the rules, because the role of doctor was accepted as giving the right to command oeA1
- Answer: A doctor holds a position at the top of the hospital hierarchy that nurses accept as having the right to give instructions; the nurses therefore began to follow an order from an unknown caller even though it broke the rules.
Question 11
- identifies that the finding shows a number of people did not obey (about 35% stopped before the highest level) even though they received the same orders, so the agentic state cannot be the whole explanation oeM1
- explains the limitation, e.g. it cannot account for individual differences in who obeys and who resists, so it is an incomplete explanation and other factors such as personality must be considered oeA1
- Answer: If obedience were only a shift into the agentic state, everyone given the same orders would obey; because some resisted, the explanation cannot account for individual differences and is incomplete.
Question 12
- defines moral strain as the discomfort or tension felt when actions ordered by authority conflict with personal morals oeM1
- offers a reason, e.g. the person still recognises the action as wrong but feels unable to refuse because responsibility is perceived as belonging to the authority oeA1
- explains why this matters, e.g. moral strain shows obedience can involve internal conflict rather than absence of conscience oeA1
- Answer: Moral strain is the tension experienced when someone obeys an authority to do something they recognise as wrong. It occurs because the person still has moral awareness but feels unable to refuse and believes responsibility lies with the authority, showing obedience can coexist with internal conflict.
Question 13
- identifies one binding factor, e.g. denying personal responsibility or shifting blame to the authority figure oeM1
- explains how this factor reduces resistance, e.g. reducing feelings of guilt so the person is less likely to disobey oeA1
- identifies a second binding factor, e.g. focusing on the task or using gradual increases in demands (gradual commitment) oeM1
- Answer: Examples: (1) Shifting or denying personal responsibility to the authority, which reduces guilt and makes refusal less likely. (2) Focusing on the immediate task or accepting small incremental demands, which makes larger harmful acts seem acceptable over time.
Question 14
- explains legitimacy of authority: obedience occurs because the person perceives the authority as having the right to give orders within a social hierarchy oeM1
- explains agentic state: obedience occurs because the person sees themselves as an agent, shifting responsibility to the authority and therefore feeling able to follow orders oeM1
- gives a contrast or implication, e.g. legitimacy focuses on social structure while agentic state focuses on cognitive shift in responsibility oeA1
- Answer: Legitimacy of authority says people obey because society grants certain figures the right to command. The agentic state says people obey because they psychologically see themselves as an agent and shift responsibility to that authority. The contrast is that legitimacy points to social structure, whereas agentic state emphasises an internal cognitive shift.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.