Milgram's Baseline Study Into Obedience: Procedure and Findings - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
9 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Milgram's Baseline Study Into Obedience: Procedure and Findings revision guideWrite-in editionMore A Level Psychology practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 2 of A Level Psychology Topic Workbook 1 and chapter 2 of A Level Psychology 10-Minute Tests 1.
1.1 Milgram's Baseline Study Into Obedience: Procedure and Findings
Question 1
- the learner was a confederate who pretended to receive electric shocks and gave pre scripted incorrect answers when tested by the participant, who acted as the 'teacher' oeB1
- Answer: The learner was a confederate who feigned being shocked and produced scripted wrong answers while the real participant, as teacher, administered the shocks.
Question 2
- "Please continue" or "Please go on" as a standard prod oeB1
- "The experiment requires that you continue" or "You must go on" as a standard prod oeB1
- Answer: Examples of prods: "Please continue" and "The experiment requires that you continue."
Question 3
- states that Orne and Holland argued participants may have suspected the shocks were fake, challenging the realism of the situation oeM1
- explains that if participants guessed the true nature of the study, their behaviour may not reflect genuine obedience in real life, reducing ecological validity oeA1
- Answer: Orne and Holland argued participants might have guessed the shocks were fake, so their behaviour may not reflect genuine real world obedience, reducing ecological validity.
Question 4
- applies Milgram's finding that a majority of participants obeyed an authoritative figure and continued to the maximum shock (65%) oeM1
- links the military officer to the experimenter's authoritative role in Milgram's procedure, showing the recruit may feel duty bound to obey oeA1
- applies the idea that experimenter prods in Milgram's study encouraged continuation, analogous to orders and pressure in a military setting oeM1
- explains that the recruit may feel the order comes from a legitimate authority and that refusal could have social or career consequences, so they comply oeA1
- applies Milgram's observation of participants showing distress while obeying, to explain why the recruit may feel distressed yet still follow orders oeM1
- explains that obedience under distress was characteristic of Milgram's participants, so similar situational pressures in the military can produce obedience despite personal discomfort oeA1
- Answer: Milgram found 65% obeyed an authoritative experimenter to the maximum, and his scripted prods encouraged continuation. In a military setting the officer plays a similar authoritative role and may give pressure or orders that seem legitimate, so the recruit may obey despite distress, paralleling Milgram's participants who showed tension yet continued.
Question 5
- explains that deception was used to create a believable situation so participants would believe they were administering real shocks and reveal genuine obedience behaviour oeM1
- evaluates that this increases internal validity because behaviour is more likely to be natural, but it raises ethical concerns because participants could not give fully informed consent oeA1
- explains that without deception the study would not replicate the conflict between authority and personal conscience that Milgram wished to observe oeM1
- evaluates that ethical costs include potential lasting distress and damage to trust in research, which may limit the acceptability and replication of such studies oeA1
- Answer: Deception made the shock situation believable so obedience could be observed, boosting internal validity. However, it prevented informed consent and risked causing serious distress, so it is ethically problematic and complicates replication.
Question 6
- Level 4 Knowledge of Milgram's baseline study is detailed and accurate. The discussion evaluates strengths and limitations coherently, using relevant evidence and reasoning. Ethical and methodological issues are explored in depth and linked to how they affect interpretation and generalisation. The answer is well structured and uses specialist terminology appropriately.13-16
- Level 3 Knowledge of the baseline study is mostly accurate with some detail. There is a balanced evaluation with some development, and ethical and methodological points are considered. The answer applies evidence and is generally well organised.9-12
- Level 2 Basic knowledge of Milgram's study is present but incomplete. Evaluation is limited or superficial, with some relevant points about ethics or methodology but little development. The answer may lack depth or full application of evidence.5-8
- Level 1 Little relevant knowledge or evaluation. The answer is largely descriptive or fragmentary, with minimal understanding of ethical or methodological implications.1-4
- Level 0 No creditable content.0
- Indicative content:
- AO1: Procedure: volunteers recruited by advert; rigged draw making participant the 'teacher' and confederate the 'learner'; learner strapped to chair; shock generator labelled 15 V to 450 V in 15 V increments with warnings at the top; participant instructed to test memory and give shocks for wrong answers; experimenter used a set of four prods when participant hesitated; shocks were fake but the participant believed them to be real.
- AO1: Findings: 65% of participants administered the highest 450 V; many participants showed signs of extreme tension such as sweating, trembling, nervous laughter and seizures; a significant minority refused to continue.
- AO3: Ethical evaluation: deception was used to create the situation but prevented informed consent; participants experienced significant stress and were not fully protected from harm; the right to withdraw was undermined by experimenter prods; debriefing and follow up were carried out but ethical standards today would not permit the baseline procedure without major changes.
- AO3: Methodological evaluation: high experimental control and a clear quantitative measure (percentage reaching 450 V) strengthen internal validity and replicability; however Orne and Holland's critique that participants may have been sceptical undermines ecological validity and questions whether behaviour reflected genuine real world obedience; sample was volunteer and all male, limiting generalisability.
- AO3: Application and implications: Milgram's findings show the power of situational pressures and perceived authority to produce obedience in ordinary people, with implications for understanding historical events and authority structures, but ethical and validity limitations constrain how directly the laboratory results can be applied to real world atrocities.
- AO3: Counterarguments and balance: supportive evidence from similar laboratory studies shows obedience can be high under authority pressure, but replication variations and cultural or temporal differences indicate obedience is not uniform; methodological strengths such as standardisation should be weighed against ethical costs and questions about realism.
Question 7
- 65 percent of participants continued to the maximum 450 volts oeB1
- approximately one third of participants stopped before reaching the highest levels, showing a range of obedience levels oeB1
- Answer: About 65% of participants went to 450 V; roughly one third stopped before the maximum, showing variation in obedience.
Question 8
- identifies a qualitative sign, e.g. sweating, trembling, stuttering, nervous laughter or seizures oeM1
- identifies a second qualitative sign oeA1
- explains that these signs indicate high tension and possible psychological harm, which matters for ethical evaluation and suggests obedience occurred under distress oeA1
- Answer: Examples: sweating and nervous laughter, or trembling and a seizure. These signs show participants experienced high tension and possible harm, so obedience occurred under stress which matters for ethics and interpretation of the behaviour.
Question 9
- identifies deception as an ethical issue, because participants were misled about the true nature of the shocks and the role of the learner oeM1
- explains why deception is a concern, e.g. it prevents informed consent and may damage trust or cause distress when the truth is revealed oeA1
- identifies lack of protection from harm, e.g. participants showed extreme stress and one or more had seizures, meaning they were not adequately protected during the procedure oeA1
- Answer: Two criticisms: deception, because participants were misled about shocks and the learner, preventing true informed consent; and lack of protection from harm, because many showed extreme stress or seizures, indicating they were not adequately protected.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.