Minority Influence: Consistency, Commitment and Flexibility - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
10 original exam-style questions - 3 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Minority Influence: Consistency, Commitment and Flexibility revision guideWrite-in editionMore A Level Psychology practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 6 of A Level Psychology Topic Workbook 1 and chapter 6 of A Level Psychology 10-Minute Tests 1.
1.5 Minority Influence: Consistency, Commitment and Flexibility
Question 1
- flexibility: minority willingness to adapt, compromise and negotiate rather than being rigidly uncompromising oeB1
- credits Nemeth as the researcher arguing flexibility increases persuasiveness of a minority oeB1
- Answer: Flexibility is the minority's willingness to adapt and negotiate rather than being rigid; Nemeth is identified with arguing that flexibility enhances minority persuasiveness.
Question 2
- identifies a methodological limitation, e.g. artificial laboratory setting and trivial task oeM1
- explains why this matters: judging slide colours is low-stakes and may not reflect complex real-world influence such as political campaigns oeA1
- identifies a second linked limitation, e.g. sample limits: all female samples or student participants oeM1
- explains effect on generalisability: findings may not generalise to male populations, workplaces or broader communities oeA1
- Answer: A key limitation is the artificial laboratory setting and trivial colour-judgement task, which is low-stakes and may not capture the complexity of real-world minority influence. Also, Moscovici used female student samples, limiting generalisability to other genders and populations.
Question 3
- names a relevant study or researcher e.g. Nemeth's work on simulated juries or related lab studies oeM1
- outlines the method briefly, e.g. tasks where a minority negotiated rather than insisted, such as juror group problem-solving studies oeA1
- states the finding: flexible minorities that showed willingness to compromise were more likely to shift the majority or to influence discussion than rigid minorities oeM1
- explains implication: flexibility aids persuasiveness by appearing reasonable and stimulating deeper processing of the minority view oeA1
- Answer: Research by Nemeth using group decision tasks found that minorities who showed flexibility and willingness to compromise were more likely to influence group discussion and sometimes change majority decisions, implying that flexibility can be more persuasive than rigid consistency.
Question 4
- synchronic consistency: the minority shows agreement among its members about the view, e.g. all members give the same opinion oeM1
- explains that synchronic consistency makes the minority appear confident and united, increasing its credibility oeA1
- diachronic consistency: the minority maintains the same position over time, repeatedly voicing the same view oeM1
- explains that diachronic consistency suggests commitment and reliability, persuading others the view deserves attention oeA1
- Answer: Synchronic consistency is when minority members agree with one another, making them appear united and credible. Diachronic consistency is when the minority keeps the same position over time, signalling commitment and reliability which can persuade others.
Question 5
- commitment: the minority shows dedication often through costly or risky acts that demonstrate belief in their position oeB1
- augmentation principle: costly or risky commitment increases the perceived validity of the minority's view, augmenting their influence oeB1
- Answer: Commitment means the minority shows dedication, often by undertaking costly or risky acts. The augmentation principle states that such costly commitment increases others' perception that the minority truly believes its view, making the minority more influential.
Question 6
- female participants were tested in groups including two confederates who formed the minority oeM1
- the group judged the colour of a series of blue slides, reporting whether each slide was blue or green oeM1
- on critical trials the two confederates consistently called the blue slides 'green', creating a consistent minority position oeA1
- the number of times naive participants agreed with the minority answer was recorded as the measure of minority influence oeA1
- Answer: Moscovici tested female participants in groups containing two confederates. The group judged whether a series of blue slides were blue or green. On critical trials the confederates consistently labelled blue slides as green and researchers recorded how often naive participants agreed with this minority answer.
Question 7
- explains augmentation principle: costly or risky acts by the minority make observers attribute stronger conviction to the minority oeM1
- applies to example: e.g. a campaign group staging a cold-night vigil in poor weather is costly, suggesting strong commitment oeA1
- explains why this matters: observers see the cost and infer genuine belief, making them more likely to take the minority seriously oeA1
- Answer: The augmentation principle says that when a minority carries out costly or risky acts, observers attribute stronger conviction to them. For example, a small campaign staging a cold-night vigil shows commitment through hardship, so bystanders infer the group genuinely believes its cause and are more likely to pay attention to its message.
Question 8
- states a strength such as empirical support: Moscovici found consistent minorities were more influential than inconsistent ones oeM1
- explains why this supports consistency as important, e.g. consistency increases perceived confidence and forces deeper processing by majorities oeA1
- states a weakness such as evidence for other factors: Nemeth's work shows flexibility is also important, and augmentation principle highlights commitment oeM1
- explains why this weakens the claim that consistency alone is sufficient to explain minority influence oeA1
- Answer: A strength is Moscovici's finding that consistent minorities were more influential than inconsistent ones, supporting consistency as an important factor because it signals confidence and attracts attention. A weakness is that other research, notably Nemeth, shows flexibility matters and the augmentation principle highlights commitment, so consistency alone cannot fully explain when minorities persuade majorities.
Question 9
- Level 4 Detailed knowledge and accurate understanding of research into minority influence. Evaluation is thoughtful and well developed, addressing methodological issues, theoretical alternatives and real-world implications. The answer integrates discussion of consistency, commitment and flexibility and uses appropriate empirical examples, such as Moscovici and Nemeth, to support points.13-16
- Level 3 Good knowledge and understanding of research into minority influence with some evaluation. Discussion addresses several relevant studies and ideas and links at least two factors, but analysis may be less thorough or slightly unbalanced.9-12
- Level 2 Some relevant knowledge of minority influence research is present but limited. Evaluation is present but superficial, and links between theory and studies are partial. Few empirical examples used or applied.5-8
- Level 1 Very limited knowledge of research into minority influence. Little or no evaluation. Answer may be a list of brief points with weak linkage to studies or theory.1-4
- Level 0 No creditable content.0
- Indicative content:
- AO1: Moscovici's blue-green slide study procedure and findings: consistent minority produced a small but notable influence; inconsistent minority produced little influence.
- AO1: Definitions of synchronic and diachronic consistency, commitment and the augmentation principle, and Nemeth's argument for flexibility.
- AO2: Application of Moscovici to theory: consistency draws attention and causes deeper processing, supporting conversion rather than mere compliance.
- AO2: Application of commitment and augmentation: costly or effortful minority acts signal conviction and increase perceived validity, attracting converts.
- AO2: Application of flexibility: Nemeth's group decision work suggests minorities that negotiate persuade more effectively by stimulating discussion and not provoking rigid rejection.
- AO3: Methodological evaluation: Moscovici's lab tasks are artificial and use limited samples so external validity is limited; however lab control allows causal inference about consistency effects.
- AO3: Supporting and challenging evidence: replications and variations show sometimes small effects and cultural or contextual moderators; some later studies show stronger effects in realistic contexts while others find limited change.
- AO3: Theoretical integration: consistency, commitment and flexibility interact; consistency and commitment attract attention and credibility, while flexibility determines whether the majority will engage and adopt at least some points, leading to a snowball effect over time.
- AO3: Practical implications and limitations: minority influence research helps explain how social change can begin, but translating lab findings to complex real-world campaigns requires caution; ethical and contextual factors also matter.
Question 10
- identifies synchronic consistency: they speak in unison and present the same proposal oeM1
- justifies that synchronic consistency makes them appear united and credible to others oeA1
- identifies commitment: they have trialled the rota privately, showing investment/effort oeM1
- explains this shows augmentation, increasing perceived sincerity of their proposal oeA1
- identifies lack of flexibility: they refuse to compromise when managers suggest small changes oeM1
- explains that inflexibility is likely harmful because Nemeth argues minorities that negotiate and adapt are more persuasive, so rigid refusal may reduce their influence oeA1
- Answer: They show synchronic consistency by speaking in unison, which makes them appear united. They show commitment by trialling the rota privately, signalling investment. They lack flexibility because they refuse to compromise; according to Nemeth this rigidity is likely to reduce persuasiveness and slow any snowballing of support.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.