Social Influence Processes and Social Change - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
8 original exam-style questions - 3 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Social Influence Processes and Social Change revision guideWrite-in editionMore A Level Psychology practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 7 of A Level Psychology Topic Workbook 1 and chapter 7 of A Level Psychology 10-Minute Tests 1.
1.6 Social Influence Processes and Social Change
Question 1
- identifies normative social influence (NSI) as the best explanation caoB1
- justification 1: residents prefer established routines and fear social disapproval or standing out if they change, showing NSI concern for belonging oeM1
- justification 2: distrust of motives prompts refusal to adopt new public behaviour because people may worry about being judged or manipulated, a social conformity concern rather than lack of information oeA1
- Answer: Normative social influence. Residents stick to routines and may fear standing out or being judged for changing, and distrust of motives reinforces a desire to conform to familiar local norms rather than accept the policy based on information alone.
Question 2
- states that consistency means the minority presents the same message over time or across its members oeB1
- explains that this makes the minority appear confident and persuasive, helping attract attention to their view oeB1
- Answer: Consistency means the minority presents the same message over time and across members; this steady position makes them appear confident and persuasive, attracting attention to their position.
Question 3
- states flexibility means the minority is willing to adapt tactics or accept compromise rather than being rigid oeB1
- explains that flexibility makes the minority appear reasonable and more likely to persuade the majority oeB1
- Answer: Flexibility means the minority adapts tactics or accepts compromise instead of being rigid; this makes them appear reasonable and increases the chance of persuading the majority.
Question 4
- states that the snowball effect is when minority influence gradually attracts more supporters, gaining momentum oeB1
- explains that as more people adopt the view the rate of change accelerates and the idea can become mainstream oeB1
- Answer: The snowball effect is when a minority gradually gains more supporters so momentum builds; as adoption increases the rate of change accelerates and the idea can become adopted widely.
Question 5
- states that Nolan et al. found messages saying that neighbours were reducing energy use caused residents to reduce their own energy consumption more than control messages about general environmental reasons oeM1
- explains that this supports the use of descriptive social norms to change behaviour in field settings oeA1
- adds that the effect indicates people follow perceived common behaviour of others, so highlighting local norms can encourage conservation oeB1
- links to relevance: shows social-norms interventions can work outside the laboratory, in real communities oeB1
- Answer: Nolan et al. found that messages stating neighbours were reducing energy use produced greater reductions in residents' energy use than general messages; this supports using descriptive social-norms messages in real-world campaigns because people tend to follow perceived common behaviour locally.
Question 6
- identifies a field experiment method: e.g. sending tailored messages to households saying most neighbours do not litter, with a control group receiving general anti-littering information oeM1
- explains a practical data collection method: e.g. measure litter counts in public bins and on streets before and after messaging, or use unobtrusive observations of people dropping litter oeA1
- gives one advantage: high ecological validity since the intervention is tested in a real community and behaviour is observed in a natural setting oeM1
- explains why this advantage matters: findings better predict real-world impact and policy relevance than lab studies oeA1
- gives one limitation: field experiments have less experimental control and more potential confounding variables, such as weather or other local campaigns oeM1
- explains the limitation: uncontrolled variables make establishing a clear causal link between the message and behaviour harder and can reduce internal validity oeA1
- Answer: Use a field experiment like Nolan et al.: send descriptive-norm messages to some neighbourhoods and neutral messages to controls, then collect litter counts or unobtrusive observations before and after. Advantage: high ecological validity so results predict real-world behaviour and inform policy. Limitation: less experimental control and possible confounds such as weather or other local events that make causality harder to establish.
Question 7
- Level 4 Knowledge of social influence processes and social change is accurate, detailed and well organised. Discussion is thorough and evaluative, integrating AO1, AO2 and AO3 material. The answer considers both supporting and challenging evidence, applies concepts to examples or scenarios effectively, and shows clear chains of reasoning about mechanisms and consequences.13-16
- Level 3 Knowledge is clear and mostly accurate with some detail. Discussion includes evaluation and some integration of evidence and application. Some points are developed and supported, though coverage may be less comprehensive or less analytical than top band answers.9-12
- Level 2 Knowledge is present but limited or partially accurate. Discussion is largely descriptive with limited evaluation or application. Points are brief and not developed into sustained argument.5-8
- Level 1 Knowledge is minimal and statements are superficial. Little or no relevant evaluation or application. Answer may be disorganised or fragmentary.1-4
- Level 0 No creditable content.0
- Indicative content:
- AO1: Minority influence processes: consistency, commitment and flexibility help minorities persuade the majority; the snowball effect describes how small shifts can become large-scale change over time.
- AO1: Majority processes: conformity via normative social influence (NSI) and informational social influence (ISI) maintain existing norms but can also enable rapid spread once a new norm is perceived as common.
- AO2: Application: minority campaigns use consistency and commitment to attract attention and credibility; flexibility helps negotiate incremental policy shifts; early adopters create a snowball effect that turns minority positions into majority practice.
- AO2: Nolan et al. shows descriptive norm messages can change real behaviour, demonstrating how majority-like cues can be used deliberately in interventions to encourage desired behaviours such as energy saving or recycling.
- AO3: Evaluation of minority influence: supporting evidence shows minorities can initiate change but effects are often slow and indirect; minority influence is strengthened by clear, consistent messaging but can be undermined by perceived extremism or lack of flexibility.
- AO3: Evaluation of social-norms interventions: field studies like Nolan et al. have high ecological validity and real policy relevance, but field interventions risk confounds and ethical issues if messaging misrepresents behaviour or pressures vulnerable groups.
- AO3: Role of ISI and NSI: ISI explains change where uncertainty exists and people look for information, NSI explains public compliance when people want social approval; both can explain resistance where entrenched norms or distrust reduce the impact of persuasive messages.
- AO3: Social cryptomnesia: societies may adopt new norms but forget the originators; this has implications for historical recognition and for the morale of activists, and means models of change must account for how memory and attribution affect long-term outcomes.
- AO3: Counter-evidence and individual differences: not everyone conforms or changes; personality, prior commitment, cultural context and competing information sources affect whether influence leads to social change; Perrin and Spencer type replications show variability across time and culture.
- AO3: Practical considerations: ethical use of social-norms messaging, the need for accurate descriptive information, monitoring unintended consequences, and combining minority-led activism with institutional change to secure lasting outcomes.
Question 8
- applies consistency: e.g. volunteers present the same factual message at stalls and in leaflets over time, building credibility oeM1
- applies commitment: e.g. volunteers share personal sacrifice or long term involvement, showing they believe in the campaign and increasing persuasion oeM1
- applies flexibility: e.g. volunteers negotiate with clinics to offer convenient appointments and compromise on approaches to reach hesitant residents oeM1
- applies snowball effect: e.g. early adopters influence friends and family so uptake grows over months, accelerating into wider community acceptance oeA1
- Answer: Consistency: repeat the same factual message at stalls and in materials so the community perceives a steady position. Commitment: volunteers share personal stories and long term dedication to increase credibility. Flexibility: negotiate with clinics and adjust tactics to address concerns so the minority seems reasonable. Snowball effect: initial adopters persuade friends and family, and uptake accelerates until vaccination becomes normal in the neighbourhood.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.