Medicine in Britain, c1250-present: Change and Continuity in Ideas About the Cause of Disease - Worksheets, Questions and Revision
12 original exam-style questions - 4 pages of questions with a full mark scheme - free printable PDF.
Medicine in Britain, c1250-present: Change and Continuity in Ideas About the Cause of Disease revision guideMore GCSE History practiceMock exams
This topic is chapter 7 of GCSE History Topic Workbook 1 and chapter 7 of GCSE History 10-Minute Tests 1.
1.7 Medicine in Britain, c1250-present: Change and Continuity in Ideas About the Cause of Disease
Question 1
- Rosalind FranklinB1
- Answer: Rosalind Franklin
Question 2
- genes/genetics (accept 'genetic inheritance')B1
- Answer: Genetics (genetic inheritance)
Question 3
- Level 1 Identifies one or two general reasons for the faster pace of change, with little or no supporting detail or explanation.1-2
- Level 2 Identifies and begins to explain one reason, supported by accurate detail.3-4
- Level 3 Explains two reasons for the faster pace of change, each supported by accurate and relevant detail.5-6
- Level 4 Explains two or more reasons in a well-developed, logically structured way, supported throughout by precise and accurate detail, showing how the reasons connect.7-8
- Indicative content:
- Scientific and technological advances, especially the improved microscope, finally allowed scientists such as Pasteur and Koch to directly observe the microorganisms that cause disease, providing the first genuinely accurate explanation to replace centuries of theories such as the Four Humours and miasma.
- Growing scientific institutions and methods of communication, including specialist scientific journals and international scientific contact, allowed new findings to be tested, confirmed and shared more quickly than in earlier periods, when a new idea, such as Vesalius's anatomy, might spread only slowly.
- Government and public interest in disease grew because of the pressures of rapid industrialisation and urbanisation, which created new, visible public health crises such as cholera outbreaks that increased the incentive to find and accept accurate explanations.
- Earlier individual breakthroughs, such as Vesalius's anatomical corrections and Harvey's proof of circulation, had already established a scientific tradition of testing ideas by observation and experiment rather than simply accepting ancient authority, which made society more receptive to Germ Theory when it appeared.
Question 4
- Level 1 Identifies one or two general reasons for the theory's long survival, with little or no supporting detail or explanation.1-2
- Level 2 Identifies and begins to explain one reason, supported by accurate detail.3-4
- Level 3 Explains two reasons for the theory's long survival, each supported by accurate and relevant detail.5-6
- Level 4 Explains two or more reasons in a well-developed, logically structured way, supported throughout by precise and accurate detail, showing how the reasons connect.7-8
- Indicative content:
- The Four Humours theory, developed by ancient Greek and Roman writers such as Hippocrates and Galen, appeared to fit many everyday observations, such as fevers or the apparent effects of bloodletting, so it was not obviously wrong to contemporaries without a scientific alternative.
- For much of the medieval and early modern period, the Church controlled university education and approved which ideas could be taught, protecting the theory's status because it did not directly contradict religious teaching.
- No effective way existed to observe the real cause of infectious disease until the microscope was sufficiently developed and used systematically by scientists such as Pasteur and Koch in the nineteenth century, so no genuine alternative explanation was available for centuries.
- Because doctors were trained in the theory at university and their professional authority depended on it, there was limited institutional incentive to question it, even as some individuals, such as Vesalius and Harvey, began to correct specific related errors in anatomy and physiology.
Question 5
- Level 1 Shows limited relevant knowledge of ideas about the cause of disease across the period, and offers only a simple, unsupported opinion on the statement.1-4
- Level 2 Shows some relevant knowledge and identifies relevant factors, but the argument is only partly supported and lacks a developed judgement on how far the statement is accurate.5-8
- Level 3 Shows good relevant knowledge and explains a range of factors, reaching a supported judgement on how far the statement is accurate, with some links made between factors.9-12
- Level 4 Shows precise, well-selected knowledge and explains a range of factors in a balanced way, reaching a fully supported and sustained judgement on how far the statement is accurate, with clear analytical links between factors and consistently accurate use of specialist historical terminology.13-16
- Indicative content:
- Supporting the statement: the invention and improvement of the microscope was essential to Pasteur's and Koch's nineteenth-century proof that specific germs cause specific diseases, something no earlier period could have discovered without the technology to see microorganisms.
- Supporting the statement: the discovery of the structure of DNA in 1953, made possible by X-ray diffraction technology used by Rosalind Franklin and Maurice Wilkins, opened up a scientific, genetic understanding of disease that had no equivalent in earlier centuries.
- Against the statement: individuals mattered greatly regardless of the technology available to them, for example Vesalius's willingness to challenge Galen through his own human dissections in an age without modern scientific instruments.
- Against the statement: religion and the Church shaped which ideas could be taught and believed for centuries, showing that social and institutional power, not only scientific capability, controlled which explanations of disease were accepted at a given time.
- Against the statement: communication and the spread of ideas, such as the printing press from the sixteenth century, scientific institutions like the Royal Society from 1660, and later widespread literacy and publishing, were what allowed a scientific discovery to become widely accepted knowledge rather than remaining an isolated finding.
- A balanced judgement might argue that new technology made genuinely new discoveries possible, especially the microscope and X-ray diffraction, but that other factors, particularly the power of the Church in the earlier periods and the spread of communication in the later periods, determined how quickly and widely those discoveries actually changed accepted ideas.
Question 6
- Galen placed first and Vesalius placed secondB1
- Koch placed third and Watson and Crick placed fourthB1
- Answer: Galen, then Vesalius, then Koch, then Watson and Crick.
Question 7
- Louis PasteurB1
- Answer: Louis Pasteur
Question 8
- identifies a valid abandoned idea, e.g. supernatural/religious explanations such as disease being sent by God as a punishment for sin, or astrological explanationsB1
- supporting detail, e.g. by 1900 Germ Theory (from 1861) had given doctors a scientifically tested alternative that these older explanations could not compete withB1
- Answer: E.g. religious or astrological explanations for disease, largely abandoned by scientifically trained doctors once Germ Theory was accepted.
Question 9
- miasma (theory)B1
- Answer: Miasma theory
Question 10
- it allowed scientists to see microorganisms (germs/bacteria) that were invisible to the naked eyeB1
- so they could directly observe and identify the specific organisms responsible for particular diseases, rather than relying only on theoryB1
- Answer: The microscope let scientists see and identify the specific microorganisms causing disease, rather than relying only on theory.
Question 11
- Robert KochB1
- Answer: Robert Koch
Question 12
- identifies a valid factor, e.g. the printing press, or the founding of scientific institutions and journalsB1
- supporting detail, e.g. the printing press allowed Vesalius's illustrated findings (1543) to be copied accurately across Europe; or the Royal Society (founded 1660) published Philosophical Transactions, letting scientists share and check each other's findingsB1
- Answer: E.g. the printing press, which spread Vesalius's illustrated findings; or the Royal Society's journal, which let scientists share and check discoveries.
Mark your answers
Check answers without an account. Some answers can be checked automatically; use the mark scheme to mark the rest.