A Level Politics Topic Workbook 2 includes Parliament's Legislative Process and Scrutiny of the Executive (from page 3); The Relationship Between the Executive and Parliament (from page 8); The Judiciary: Independence, Neutrality and the Supreme Court (from page 12); Judicial Review and the Judiciary's Power Over Government (from page 16); Parliamentary Sovereignty and the Impact of Devolution (from page 21); The Structures and Powers of the Devolved Governments of the UK (from page 26); The Comparative Powers of the Commons and Lords, and Lords Reform (from page 31); Referendums as an Instrument of Constitutional Change in the UK (from page 35); Conservatism (from page 40); Core Ideas and Principles of Liberalism (from page 45); Classical and Modern Liberalism: Tensions Within the Tradition (from page 50); Liberal Thinkers: John Locke and Mary Wollstonecraft (from page 55); Liberal Thinkers: John Stuart Mill and John Rawls (from page 60); Core Ideas and Principles of Socialism (from page 65); Revolutionary Socialism and Social Democracy: Tensions Within the Tradition (from page 69); Socialist Thinkers: Karl Marx and Rosa Luxemburg (from page 74).
Worked question 6 - Referendums as an Instrument of Constitutional Change in the UK
Open the included worksheet
Explain how the 2011 Welsh referendum altered the constitutional relationship between the Senedd and the UK Parliament, and why this illustrates the advisory-parliamentary tension.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 6
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | Identifies that the 2011 referendum authorised the Senedd to make primary legislation in devolved areas without needing a Legislative Competence Order from Westminster |
| B1 | Identifies the change reduced direct Westminster control over Welsh law-making in devolved fields |
| B1 | Explains that Parliament still retained sovereignty and could in theory legislate to alter the Senedd's powers, showing Westminster remains the ultimate legal authority |
| B1 | Explains that the referendum result was implemented by Parliament passing the necessary legislation, illustrating referendums are politically powerful but require parliamentary action |
| B1 | Explains why this is an example of the advisory-parliamentary tension: the Senedd gained popular legitimacy for greater autonomy but the legal authority depended on Acts of Parliament |
| B1 | Offers an example or brief development, e.g. how the change streamlined Welsh law-making and was welcomed as enhancing democratic accountability in Wales |
- Answer: The 2011 Welsh referendum authorised the Senedd to make primary legislation in devolved areas without requiring Westminster to grant Legislative Competence Orders. This reduced Westminster oversight in devolved law-making, but the legal basis for the change remained parliamentary: Parliament enacted the necessary legislation to give effect to the popular decision. The case therefore shows the tension between popular ratification and parliamentary sovereignty, since referendums secure political legitimacy while Parliament remains the ultimate legal authority.
Question 3 - Referendums as an Instrument of Constitutional Change in the UK
Open the included worksheet
Explain the significance of the Edinburgh Agreement and the Section 30 order in establishing the legal basis for the 2014 Scottish independence referendum.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 3
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | Identifies that the Edinburgh Agreement (2012) was a political agreement between the UK and Scottish governments to hold a lawful referendum |
| B1 | Identifies that a Section 30 order under the Scotland Act was used to temporarily transfer the power to hold the referendum to the Scottish Parliament |
| B1 | Explains that these arrangements gave the referendum clear legal and political legitimacy and removed uncertainty about whether Holyrood could lawfully hold such a vote |
| B1 | Explains that despite this legal footing, the referendum result still required political implementation through both Scottish and UK governments, illustrating the joint role of negotiation and parliamentary action |
| B1 | Explains why this shows the role of negotiated agreements in making referendums effective tools for constitutional change, while reaffirming parliamentary sovereignty and intergovernmental cooperation |
- Answer: The Edinburgh Agreement provided a political understanding that a legal referendum would be held, and a Section 30 order temporarily granted the Scottish Parliament the competency to hold the 2014 independence referendum. This gave the referendum legal legitimacy and clarity, showing how negotiated transfers of power between governments can enable popular ratification while ultimately relying on statutory mechanisms and parliamentary authority.
Question 2 - Referendums as an Instrument of Constitutional Change in the UK
Open the included worksheet
State three constitutional implications of the 1998 Good Friday Agreement referendum result for Northern Ireland and UK constitutional arrangements.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 2
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | Identifies that the referendum endorsed the Good Friday Agreement, enabling the UK and Irish governments to legislate to implement it |
| B1 | Identifies that the result led to the Northern Ireland Act 1998, creating the Northern Ireland Assembly and Executive with devolved powers |
| B1 | Identifies that the referendum entrenched the principle of consent for Northern Ireland's constitutional status, tying any future change to majority support among the people of Northern Ireland |
| B1 | Identifies that the referendum demonstrated how international agreements, domestic referendums and parliamentary legislation combined to produce constitutional change |
| B1 | Identifies that, despite popular endorsement, legal implementation required Parliament and the governments involved to enact powers and institutions, showing parliamentary sovereignty remains central |
- Answer: The 1998 referendum endorsed the Good Friday Agreement and led to the Northern Ireland Act 1998 establishing the Assembly and Executive. It entrenched the principle of consent for any change to Northern Ireland's status, illustrated how referendums, international agreements and Acts of Parliament can work together to effect constitutional change, and showed that parliamentary legislation was required to implement the popular decision.
Question 4 - The Structures and Powers of the Devolved Governments of the UK
Open the included worksheet
Explain two ways in which the devolution settlements of Scotland and Wales differ under the reserved-powers model as of the Wales Act 2017 and Scotland Act 2016. Include a brief supporting example for one of the differences.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 4
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | identifies one valid difference, e.g. Scotland has wider income-tax powers than Wales, oe |
| B1 | explains that difference, e.g. Scotland can set rates and bands for non-savings, non-dividend income tax, while Wales can vary rates but not the UK-set bands, oe |
| B1 | identifies a second valid difference, e.g. justice and policing are devolved in Scotland but reserved in Wales, oe |
| B1 | explains that difference, e.g. Scotland can legislate and make policy in those areas through its separate legal system, while Wales remains within the England-and-Wales jurisdiction, oe |
| B1 | adds a relevant supporting example for either difference, e.g. Scotland can create a different income-tax band structure, while Wales cannot alter the bands; accept other accurate illustrations of the chosen contrasts |
- Answer: Scotland has wider income-tax powers: it can set rates and bands for non-savings, non-dividend income, while Wales can vary rates but not the UK-set bands. For example, Scotland can create a different band structure. Justice and policing are devolved in Scotland, enabling policy and legislation within its separate legal system, while these areas remain reserved for Wales within the England-and-Wales jurisdiction. Other accurate, explained differences with a supporting example are accepted.
Question 3 - The Structures and Powers of the Devolved Governments of the UK
Open the included worksheet
Explain briefly what the reserved-powers model means for the Scottish Parliament under the Scotland Acts.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 3
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | identifies that under the reserved-powers model, the Scottish Parliament can legislate on all matters that are not explicitly reserved to Westminster |
| B1 | gives a correct example of a devolved area, e.g. education or health |
| B1 | notes that reserved matters are listed and remain the competence of the UK Parliament |
- Answer: Under the reserved-powers model the Scottish Parliament can legislate on all matters that are not explicitly reserved to the UK Parliament; devolved areas include education and health, while reserved matters are listed in statute and remain Westminster competence.
Question 2 - Parliament's Legislative Process and Scrutiny of the Executive
Open the included worksheet
Explain the purpose of Prime Minister's Questions (PMQs) in the House of Commons and outline one limitation of PMQs as a tool for sustained scrutiny of government policy.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 2
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | Identifies the purpose, for example to allow MPs to question the Prime Minister directly on current issues and government actions in a high visibility forum |
| B1 | Develops the purpose, for example PMQs promotes direct political accountability, enables opposition to challenge the PM, and signals issues to the media and public |
| B1 | Identifies a limitation, for example the short, time-limited format encourages brief answers and theatrical exchanges rather than detailed examination |
| B1 | Develops the limitation, for example it prevents thorough evidence-based probing and can prioritise spectacle over detailed policy interrogation |
- Answer: PMQs allows MPs to question the Prime Minister directly, providing high public visibility and immediate political accountability; it enables the opposition to challenge the PM and places issues on the public agenda. A limitation is the short, adversarial format, which encourages brief answers and theatrical exchanges rather than sustained, evidence-based scrutiny, limiting its usefulness for detailed examination of complex policy.
Question 3 - Parliament's Legislative Process and Scrutiny of the Executive
Open the included worksheet
State two formal parliamentary mechanisms used specifically to scrutinise the executive and name the principal feature of each.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 3
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|
| B1 | One valid mechanism named with a correct principal feature, for example Select Committees, which hold inquiries, take evidence and publish reports |
| B1 | A second valid mechanism named with a correct principal feature, for example Prime Minister's Questions, which provide a weekly oral question and answer session with the Prime Minister in the House of Commons |
- Answer: Select Committees, which hold inquiries, take evidence from witnesses and publish reports; Prime Minister's Questions, a weekly oral question and answer session where MPs question the Prime Minister directly.