Worked question 12 - The Chi-Squared Test: Rationale, Application and Critical Values
Answer and mark scheme
Question 12
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| M1 | calculates the row totals, column totals and grand total correctly, e.g. leaflet total 60, no-leaflet total 60, contacted total 39, not contacted total 81, grand total 120 oe |
| M1 | shows how to calculate an expected value using E = (row total x column total) / grand total and substitutes correct numbers for at least one cell oe |
| A1 | gives the correct expected value for the contacted, leaflet cell as 19.5 and for the contacted, no-leaflet cell as 19.5 oe |
| A1 | gives the correct expected value for the not-contacted, leaflet cell as 40.5 and for the not-contacted, no-leaflet cell as 40.5 oe |
| M1 | substitutes O and E into the formula X2 = sum((O - E)2 / E) for each of the four cells oe |
| A1 | calculates and states the numerical value for X2 to two decimal places as 3.08 awrt 3.08 oe |
| M1 | calculates degrees of freedom correctly for the 2x2 table as df = (2 - 1) x (2 - 1) = 1 oe |
| A1 | states the correct critical value at p ≤ 0.05 for df = 1 as 3.841 and compares it with the calculated X2 oe |
| A1 | draws the correct conclusion that X2 = 3.08 < 3.841 so the result is not significant at p ≤ 0.05 and the null hypothesis is retained oe |
- Answer: Totals: leaflet 60, no-leaflet 60, contacted 39, not contacted 81, grand total 120. Expected frequencies: contacted, leaflet = (60 x 39)/120 = 19.5; contacted, no-leaflet = 19.5; not contacted, leaflet = (60 x 81)/120 = 40.5; not contacted, no-leaflet = 40.5. Components: (24 - 19.5)2/19.5 = 1.0385, (36 - 40.5)2/40.5 = 0.5, (15 - 19.5)2/19.5 = 1.0385, (45 - 40.5)2/40.5 = 0.5. Sum X2 = 3.077 = 3.08 (2 dp). df = 1. Critical value at p ≤ 0.05 is 3.841. Since 3.08 < 3.841 the result is not significant at p ≤ 0.05; retain the null hypothesis, no clear association between leaflet and contacting counselling in this sample.








