Worked question 4 - Human Defences, Vaccination and Drug Development
Vaccination Coverage and Whooping Cough Cases
Original scenario written for Revision Library, styled on the format of UK public health vaccination-coverage reporting (e.g. UKHSA/NHS data summaries). No copied text or figures.
Whooping cough (pertussis) is a bacterial infection that can be serious in young babies. In one country, a national vaccination programme against whooping cough was introduced. Before the programme began, 84000 cases of whooping cough were recorded per year. Several years after the programme began, this fell to 3150 cases per year.
At a secondary school in the same country, 1500 students attend. School nurse records show that 88% of these students have received the MMR (measles, mumps and rubella) vaccine. Public health guidance states that at least 95% vaccination coverage is generally needed to achieve herd immunity against measles within a school-sized population.
Answer and mark scheme
Question 4
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| B1 | (a) e.g. sterilise the Petri dishes, agar and equipment (for example, using an autoclave) before use - to kill any microorganisms already present, preventing contamination of the culture (oe; accept any one valid technique with a correct purpose) |
| B1 | (a) e.g. flame the neck of the bottle containing the bacterial culture (and the inoculating loop) immediately before and after use - to kill microorganisms in the air that could fall in and contaminate the culture, or that could escape (oe; accept any one different valid technique with a correct purpose) |
| B1 | (b) 37 C is the temperature at which many pathogens that could harm humans grow best/fastest (oe) |
| B1 | (b) incubating at a lower temperature (25 C or below) reduces the risk of culturing/growing such pathogens, while still allowing the (harmless) bacterium used in this investigation to grow (oe) |
| M1 | (c) area = π x r2 |
| M1 | (c) area = π x 62 (= π x 36) |
| A1 | (c) 113 mm2 (awrt 113 mm2) cao |
| B1 | (d) antibiotic X produced a larger zone of inhibition (113 mm2, allow ft from the candidate's answer to (c)) than antibiotic Y (78.5 mm2) (oe; must show or state a clear numerical comparison) |
| B1 | (d) a larger zone of inhibition means the bacterium is more strongly inhibited by / more sensitive to that antibiotic, so antibiotic X is more effective against this bacterium than antibiotic Y (oe) |
| B1 | (e) valid improvement, e.g. test each antibiotic against more than one species/strain of bacterium (oe; accept: repeat the investigation several times for each antibiotic and calculate a mean zone area) |
| B1 | (e) reason linked to the chosen improvement, e.g. this shows whether the pattern (X more effective than Y) applies generally, rather than being specific to just one type of bacterium (oe; if repeats chosen: reduces the effect of anomalous results/random error on the mean) |
| B1 | (e) further valid related point, e.g. testing a wider range of antibiotic concentrations on the discs would show whether the difference depends on dose, not just the antibiotic used (oe) |
| B1 | (e) correctly links the suggested improvement to increased confidence in the conclusion (e.g. explicitly states that this would make it more certain that antibiotic X really is more effective, rather than the difference being due to chance or to the specific bacterium tested) (oe) |
- (a) Answer: Any two of: sterilising equipment/agar before use; flaming the culture bottle neck and inoculating loop; working near a Bunsen flame; taping (not sealing) the lid - each to prevent unwanted microorganisms contaminating or escaping the culture.
- (b) Answer: Incubating below 25 C avoids growing conditions that favour pathogens that could infect humans (which grow best near body temperature, 37 C), keeping the investigation safer while still allowing the test bacterium to grow.
- (c) Answer: 113 mm2
- (d) Answer: Antibiotic X (zone area 113 mm2) is more effective than antibiotic Y (zone area 78.5 mm2), because a larger zone of inhibition shows the bacterium is more strongly inhibited by antibiotic X.
- (e) Answer: Test each antibiotic against more than one species/strain of bacterium (or repeat the investigation and calculate a mean zone area for each antibiotic); this shows whether antibiotic X really is more effective in general, increasing confidence that the difference is real rather than due to chance or to the one bacterium tested.









