Worked question 8 - Atomic Structure and the Development of the Model
A Model Under Construction
Original text written for Revision Library.
For most of the 19th century, scientists pictured the atom as a tiny, solid sphere that could not be divided into anything smaller. This changed in 1897, when J.J. Thomson discovered the electron, a negatively charged particle far lighter than a whole atom. Since atoms themselves have no overall charge, Thomson reasoned that the negative electrons had to be balanced by some positive charge, and he proposed the 'plum pudding' model: a ball of positive charge with tiny negative electrons scattered through it. This idea held for over a decade, until Ernest Rutherford asked two of his students, Hans Geiger and Ernest Marsden, to fire alpha particles at a very thin sheet of gold foil. Almost all of the alpha particles passed straight through, as expected, but a small number were deflected through large angles, and a very small number bounced almost straight back. Rutherford later said it was 'as if you had fired a fifteen-inch shell at a piece of tissue paper and it came back and hit you.' The plum pudding model could not explain this, so Rutherford proposed a new nuclear model: almost all of an atom's mass and all of its positive charge are concentrated in a tiny, dense nucleus at the centre, surrounded by mostly empty space. Niels Bohr then adapted this model further, suggesting that electrons do not orbit at random but occupy fixed shells, or energy levels, at set distances from the nucleus. Finally, in 1932, James Chadwick provided the evidence needed to show that the nucleus also contains neutral particles called neutrons, alongside positively charged protons. This gave scientists the model of the atom still used today, and explained why atoms of the same element can have different masses: isotopes.
A student repeats a version of the experiment, firing α particles at a thin gold foil and counting how many are detected at different angles of deflection, using a fixed counting time.
| Angle of deflection | Number of α particles detected |
|---|---|
| 0 to 10 degrees (undeflected, almost straight through) | 8200 |
| 10 to 90 degrees (small/moderate deflection) | 140 |
| More than 90 degrees (large deflection, some almost straight back) | 6 |
Total α particles detected = 8346
Answer and mark scheme
Question 8
| Credit | Answer or working |
|---|---|
| B1 | (a) a source of α particles fires (emits) a narrow beam of α particles at a very thin sheet of gold foil, oe |
| B1 | (a) a detector (e.g. a movable fluorescent/scintillation screen) placed around the foil records the number of α particles scattered at each angle, usually inside a vacuum chamber so the α particles are not absorbed by air, oe |
| M1 | (b) total number of α particles detected = 8200 + 140 + 6 (= 8346) |
| M1 | (b) percentage = (6 / 8346) x 100, oe |
| A1 | (b) = 0.072% (2 s.f.), awrt 0.072% |
| B1 | (c) most α particles (8200 out of 8346) did pass straight through with little deflection, which was consistent with the prediction |
| B1 | (c) however, a small number (140) were deflected by a small to moderate angle, and a very small number (6) were deflected by more than 90 degrees, some almost straight back |
| B1 | (c) this large-angle deflection was not predicted by the plum pudding model, since spread-out (dilute) positive charge could not repel an α particle strongly enough to reverse its direction, oe |
| B1 | (d) the nucleus must be very small compared with the whole atom, since most α particles pass through empty space without being deflected |
| B1 | (d) the positive charge of the atom must be concentrated in a small volume (the nucleus), because only a concentrated charge could repel/deflect an α particle through a large angle |
| B1 | (d) most of the mass of the atom must be concentrated in the nucleus, because only a very massive object could reverse the direction of a fast-moving α particle, oe |
| B1 | (e) repeat the count at each angle (for the same length of time) and calculate a mean, oe e.g. use a longer counting time, or more than one detector |
| B1 | (f) any valid control variable with a correct reason, e.g. the thickness of the gold foil (or the activity/energy of the α source, or the counting time) should be kept constant, because changing it would also change the pattern of deflection, making it hard to link the results only to the structure of the atom, oe |
- (a) Answer: An α source directs a narrow beam of α particles at thin gold foil; a movable detector around the foil (in a vacuum) records how many α particles are scattered at each angle.
- (b) Answer: 0.072% (2 s.f.)
- (c) Answer: Most particles passed straight through, supporting the idea of mostly empty space, but a very small number were deflected by more than 90 degrees, which spread-out positive charge (as in the plum pudding model) could not explain.
- (d) Answer: The nucleus is very small compared with the atom, but concentrates almost all of the atom's positive charge and most of its mass.
- (e) Answer: Repeat the count at each angle (for the same counting time) and take a mean, to reduce the effect of the random nature of radioactive emission.
- (f) Answer: E.g. the thickness of the gold foil must be kept the same, otherwise a thicker patch could deflect more particles for a reason unrelated to atomic structure.









